Exploring Legal Service Models in the Context of “Internet Plus” Thinking
Release date:
2019-07-25 09:09
Source:
Exploring Legal Service Models in the Context of “Internet Plus” Thinking
(Zhao Qingshu and Zhang Yi, Shandong Chenggong Law Firm)
[Abstract] With the widespread adoption of Internet technologies, Internet‑centric thinking has permeated the legal services sector, presenting a rare opportunity for the transformation and upgrading of the traditional legal services market. This paper seeks to examine the business models of law firms and lawyers under the “Internet Plus” paradigm, with the aim of identifying innovative perspectives and pathways for leveraging Internet‑based approaches to expand and enhance legal service offerings.
[Keywords] Internet Plus, legal service model, efficiency
Richard Susskind, author of the book 'The Future of the Legal Profession', observes that legal service providers and lawyers stand at a crossroads and will undergo dramatic changes over the next 20 years—changes that will surpass those of the past two centuries. As big data applications spread across industries, the legal services sector cannot remain isolated. The 'Internet Plus' initiative offers a rare opportunity for the traditional legal services market to transform and upgrade; by adopting this new business model, firms can better understand market demand and expand both the breadth and depth of their services. To gain an early advantage and develop market share in this new wave of development, it is essential to continuously explore innovative models of legal service delivery, actively leverage one’s strengths and resources to seize opportunities under the 'Internet Plus' mindset, build strong platforms, and pursue precise market positioning, thereby driving substantial progress in the integration of legal services with internet infrastructure.
I. An Overview of New-Generation Legal Services from the Perspective of “Internet Plus”
(1) Origins: The Real-World Need for Iterative Upgrades in Legal Services
As the economy and society develop, demand for legal services has surged in tandem, giving rise to numerous new needs that traditional legal offerings cannot address. These demands can be broadly categorized as follows: First, there are cross‑disciplinary and cross‑industry needs; for example, many clients entering the internet sector find themselves unable even to decipher the relevant terminology, let alone identify the associated risks—thus necessitating specialized legal expertise. Second, there are geographically dispersed legal requirements; many issues can be resolved more efficiently only with the involvement of local counsel. Third, as Chinese enterprises advance on the global stage, a growing number of multinational corporations and cross‑border projects have emerged, entailing communication and collaboration with foreign entities and overseas lawyers. Collectively, these emerging legal service needs can be summarized by three key priorities: efficiency, cost control, and globalization.
Traditionally, legal services have relied on personal connections to identify suitable professionals, a model that offers high reliability but suffers from inefficiency. By contrast, the internet’s greatest strength lies precisely in its ability to deliver efficiency. The most profound impact of the internet is its capacity to eliminate distance, thereby dismantling industries built on information asymmetry. When information eventually achieves perfect symmetry, all inefficient business models will be rendered obsolete. The internet enables a dramatic expansion of the scope of legal services, enhancing users’ ability to find, match with, and access legal expertise while reducing costs. In turn, this reshapes users’ habits, gradually steering them toward an “Internet Plus”‑driven approach—a win‑win scenario. Consequently, as “Internet Plus” thinking gains traction, an increasing number of lawyers and law firms are turning their attention to the convergence of technology and the legal profession.
(2) Concept: Kernel + Propulsor
From the “Internet Plus” perspective, the emerging model of legal practice can be viewed as a launch vehicle: its core is specialized legal services, while the internet serves as both the booster and the accelerator.
First and foremost, professional legal expertise is the core requirement for emerging legal practice in the “Internet Plus” paradigm. Legal services cannot be delivered without lawyers and other legal professionals; lawyers constitute an indispensable occupational group. No matter how advanced Internet technologies or digital thinking may become, lawyers remain essential—and their role is likely to grow ever more closely intertwined with human interaction, particularly for industry leaders, whose work remains inseparable from the human element.
Secondly, the internet has propelled the rapid growth of legal practice on both qualitative and quantitative fronts. Internet‑driven thinking will elevate the standard of legal services. Given the convenience of the internet and the sheer volume of information available, anyone seeking assistance can now access a wealth of basic information. Although clients may lack the expertise to make precise distinctions, they can nonetheless form preliminary judgments. When they subsequently engage a lawyer for face-to-face consultation, their needs become more targeted, and they are able to validate those judgments. Consequently, lawyers are expected to maintain a high level of competence; otherwise, it will be difficult to earn client trust and deliver tangible value. The advancement of internet technologies and their pervasive integration into daily life, coupled with the inherent compatibility of standardized legal services with digital platforms, will undoubtedly spark a wave of transformation in the legal sector. Online, standardized legal services are poised to profoundly reshape the market landscape of traditional offline legal practice, having already become mainstream—and even widely accepted as a given.
II. Current Status of “Internet Plus Legal Services” in China
With the emergence of U.S.-based platforms like LegalZoom and RocketLawyer, a number of domestic entrepreneurs familiar with both law and the internet have begun to enter this space. Driven by the participation of various stakeholders, the online legal services market has started to flourish, manifesting primarily in the following four forms:
(1) Legal Big Data
The most significant transformation the internet has brought to the legal profession is, quite clearly, in the realm of big data. In the past, retrieving laws and regulations, court judgments, and various legal documents was a major challenge for legal professionals. Legal updates were rapid, yet reference works lagged behind; local regulations were often difficult to locate, and access to judicial decisions was frequently restricted. These issues not only drove up costs and made research cumbersome but also created obstacles for cross‑jurisdictional practice. With the advent of “Internet Plus Legal Big Data,” a wave of big‑data platforms has emerged. These platforms have not only streamlined and accelerated legal research but have also contributed to greater openness and transparency in China’s judicial system.
(II) Internet Marketing
In traditional legal practice, lawyers rely on referrals from personal contacts, their firm’s reputation, and their own professional network. However, this often gives rise to the “80/20 rule,” with 80% of cases concentrated in the hands of just 20% of attorneys, making client acquisition one of the biggest challenges for many young lawyers. As the internet has permeated every aspect of daily life, mobile‑device technology has become increasingly convenient and sophisticated, and internet‑based marketing—fueled by new media—has emerged alongside it. Consequently, online legal marketing platforms have also come into being.
(3) Legal Service Software
With the advancement of mobile‑device technology, many internet‑technology firms and law firms have begun developing specialized legal‑service applications that offer online access to statutes and regulations, case‑law database searches, interest‑rate calculations, litigation‑fee estimations, date‑calculation tools, corporate credit‑report inquiries, curated articles on professional practice, and even lawyer‑training resources. These apps primarily cater to legal professionals such as attorneys and in‑house counsel. Because their design, development, and ongoing operation all involve legal experts—and in some cases are managed by established law firms—they boast a high degree of specialization and practical utility, with certain solutions already becoming indispensable tools for the legal profession.
(4) Internet Law Firms
Traditional law firms are often constrained by geographic boundaries. With the exception of large firms in Beijing and Shanghai, many lawyers—though highly skilled—serve clients primarily within their own province or municipality, making it difficult to handle cross‑jurisdictional cases, let alone offshore matters. However, with the rapid advancement of internet technology, online law firms have emerged. These firms typically leverage established brick‑and‑mortar practices, gradually shifting their operations from offline to online and offering legal services across jurisdictions.
Overall, compared with other sectors in China and with the international market for online legal services, the Chinese legal profession still exhibits a relatively low level of digitalization, leaving considerable room for further development. As China’s “Internet Plus” initiative gains momentum and the Belt and Road Initiative advances abroad, Chinese lawyers should leverage these two major drivers to broaden their horizons, enhance their digital capabilities and professional expertise, and prepare for the advent of an era in which China’s legal sector becomes increasingly globalized, industrialized, and digitized.
III. Path Analysis of Legal Service Models under the “Internet Plus” Paradigm
Although China has already seen the emergence of numerous types of legal information‑technology services, and internet technologies have been applied across all facets of the legal profession, these efforts remain fragmented and lack a coherent framework. Consequently, the pressing challenge we face is how to effectively leverage “Internet Plus” thinking and platforms to expand and develop legal practice, thereby establishing a lawyer‑service model that aligns with both contemporary trends and the distinctive demands of the legal profession. Based on an analysis of the current state of China’s legal services market and existing internet‑based service models, we should proactively harness our own comparative advantages to seize the initiative in the “Internet Plus” era, build robust platforms, pursue precise market positioning, and capitalize on opportunities to actively cultivate client bases and integrate resources.
(1) The Business Model of Law Firms in the “Internet Plus” Era
1. Cooperation Models with Internet Technology Enterprises
Under the “Internet Plus” paradigm, the legal services industry is both capital‑intensive and knowledge‑intensive, requiring not only the specialized expertise of law firms but also the active involvement of internet‑technology companies. Law firms can adopt a joint‑venture model with internet‑tech enterprises to integrate technology, information services, and legal services into a unified offering for clients’ document‑management needs. In this arrangement, the law firm assumes responsibility for designing platform functionalities, overseeing the execution of outsourced tasks, and ensuring quality control, while the internet‑tech company handles the platform’s development, provides ongoing technical support, develops new features, and manages data collection. By leveraging such partnerships, law firms can broaden their service scope, compete on the global stage, and—through the use of digital platforms—reduce administrative burdens and unlock additional revenue streams from their own casework.
2. One-stop comprehensive legal service platform model
Under the “Internet Plus” paradigm, the quality of legal services hinges on their functionality, with particular emphasis on their ability to integrate and leverage resources. We should, in response to the needs of the legal profession, establish a one-stop legal service platform that seamlessly combines big‑data query and analytics, product marketing, and human‑delivered professional legal services. This is not merely an e‑commerce platform limited to channel‑driven marketing; rather, it is a more comprehensive, highly specialized business platform with a broader scope of services. The development of such a platform must be firmly grounded in internet technologies, continuously enhancing its software to support and facilitate both litigation and non‑litigation matters—providing streamlined document management and drafting, due‑diligence reporting, compliance reviews, and legal‑document retrieval services. Moreover, the legal team should be able to offer more thorough and expert research, advisory, and litigation services, enabling the platform and the lawyers to jointly build a fully integrated service ecosystem. At the same time, law firms can adopt a decentralized organizational model, transforming their internal structure into a more flexible, less hierarchically rigid framework that affords greater career‑development opportunities for junior attorneys.
Another advantage of the one-stop, integrated legal service platform model is its seamless communication. In cross‑regional and even offshore services, ease of communication and timely delivery of outcomes are paramount. Legal services hinge on effective dialogue and the exchange of legal documents; a single piece of critical evidence can determine the final outcome of a case. This platform model not only streamlines communication but also robustly safeguards information security and ensures the immediate archiving of documents.
(II) The Lawyer’s Business Model in the “Internet Plus” Era
1. Ensuring the professionalism of legal services
Law firms must uphold the professionalism of their legal services to maintain control and ensure that their clients experience a higher standard of expertise, rather than competing through price wars that undermine the quality of legal practice.
2. Precise market positioning
Different clients clearly have varying software requirements, and the complexity of services, associated costs, and implementation technologies can differ significantly. We must analyze client needs, establish clear service tiers and classifications, and determine which matters require direct attorney involvement and at what level of expertise, as well as which can be handled with computer-assisted data processing. For routine tasks, risk management, due diligence, and similar functions, computer‑assisted processing is appropriate; meanwhile, complex issues or high‑end clients and transactions should be entrusted to firm‑based attorneys. This approach not only expands our business capacity while reducing labor costs but also enables seamless complementarity between online and offline services.
3. Emphasize brand promotion and operations
First, marketing should be decoupled from practice. Traditional law firms rely heavily on individual lawyers’ personal networks for client acquisition, but this model has obvious drawbacks: young lawyers struggle to secure sufficient work and advance professionally, often spending a significant portion of their time cultivating clients and maintaining relationships. Some partners have even stopped handling cases themselves, devoting all their energy to generating new business—hardly a sustainable or virtuous cycle for the legal profession. We advocate separating marketing from practice: let the marketing team handle outreach, while practitioners focus on product innovation and legal research. This approach ensures that junior lawyers gain access to ample opportunities, grow through the platform, and become more deeply invested in its success. Meanwhile, the platform can build its brand around lawyers’ expertise, fostering mutual benefit and symbiosis, attracting fresh talent, and growing together with the team.
Second, establish an internal marketing function to complement external promotion. In addition to delivering high‑quality legal services, it is essential to raise awareness among clients about this efficient, low‑cost service model. For certain routine matters, the drafting of simple legal documents often yields low fees, making such work unattractive to law firms. However, demand for these services remains strong in China; leveraging computer‑assisted document generation and offering these services free of charge can help gradually penetrate the market. We recommend that firms set up an internal marketing team responsible for product development and outreach, while engaging a professional public‑relations agency to handle brand promotion and client management.
Conclusion
The development of the internet‑based legal services sector not only reshapes the industry’s operating environment but also profoundly influences the broader evolution of the entire internet ecosystem. The internet is no longer merely a technological concept; it has become a transformative force that redefines industries according to their unique product characteristics. Industries reimagined through internet‑centric thinking will enter the market with superior quality, giving rise to new models and disrupting existing ones, thereby achieving a seamless transition in the era of big data.
References:
① [UK] Viktor Mayer-Schönberger and Kenneth Cukier, Big Data: A Revolution That Will Transform How We Live and Work, translated by Sheng Yangyan and Zhou Taoze, Zhejiang People’s Publishing House, 2013.
② Richard Susskind: “What Will the Future of Law Be?”, translated by He Guangyue, Peking University Press.
③ Wei Jianping: “Legal Services in the Age of Internet Thinking: A Perspective from a Practicing Lawyer.”
④ Jiang Yong: “How to Build a ‘Small but Beautiful’ Law Firm Using the Internet.”
⑤ Zhang Jingbo and Cai Huadong, “An Exploration of Path Choices in Legal E‑Commerce: A Case Study of the E‑Commerce Model of TianTong Law Firm.”
⑥ Chen Weiru and Yu Zhuoxuan, “Platform Strategy: The Business Model Revolution Sweeping the Globe,” [M], CITIC Press.
Author Bio:
Zhao Qingshu (1976–), male, Han ethnicity, native of Qingdao, Shandong Province; holds a Master’s degree in Law. His research interests include corporate legal risk prevention and management, real estate law, and labor disputes. He serves as a part-time master’s supervisor at Qingdao University of Science and Technology and currently holds the position of Senior Partner and Deputy Director at Shandong Chenggong Law Firm.
Zhang Yi (born September 1983), male, native of Yichun, Jiangxi Province, holds a master’s degree in civil and commercial law, and is an attorney at Shandong Chenggong Law Firm. His research areas include public administration services and corporate legal services.
Latest News
Post a comment