Exploring the mechanisms governing corporate power in science and their role in preventing common occupational crimes in private enterprises.


  Exploring the mechanisms of corporate power in science is crucial for preventing issues in private enterprises.
  The Role of Common Official Crimes
  Shandong Chenggong Law Firm, Guo Bin and Wang Yi
  [Abstract]
  This paper investigates the state of position-related crimes in private enterprises in Qingdao in 2016 and provides a comprehensive analysis of the causes and characteristics of these offenses. It seeks to identify priority areas and practical entry points for preventing such crimes in the private sector. By designing and maintaining scientifically sound and reasonable mechanisms for the exercise of corporate authority, the study aims to keep the criminal risks associated with these offenses within levels that enterprises can bear. This enables companies to operate in compliance—without crossing legal or ethical boundaries and while upholding fundamental standards—while maximizing their potential and emerging as steady front-runners in a fiercely competitive market environment.
  [Keywords] Private enterprises, official misconduct, exercise of power
 
  I. The Current Situation of Official Crimes in Private Enterprises in the Qingdao Region
  The author conducted a statistical analysis of occupational crimes committed by private enterprises in the Qingdao region during the previous year, focusing on this specific area. In 2016, a total of 92 occupational crime cases were recorded among Qingdao’s private enterprises, their executives, and related personnel. The three most frequently charged offenses were embezzlement, illegal absorption of public deposits, and misappropriation of funds, with 18, 9, and 8 cases, respectively. Together, these top three categories accounted for 35 cases, or 38% of all occupational crime cases. This figure underscores that occupational crimes in the corporate sector now constitute a significant share of criminal cases in Qingdao, reflecting both the traditional characteristics of such offenses and the growing risk posed by the steadily rising rate of criminal activity among private enterprises. Embezzlement and misappropriation of funds have long been hallmark offenses in the corporate sphere, while crimes such as illegal absorption of public deposits—a category that has seen a marked increase in recent years—have further exacerbated the trend.
  Once a corporate criminal risk materializes, the resulting harm can be incalculable. From a market perspective, it first tarnishes the company’s reputation, hinders its growth, and may even lead to bankruptcy; moreover, it can impede the development of the entire industry, delivering a severe blow to the stability of the broader market economy. From a legal standpoint, first, the entity itself, along with relevant directly responsible individuals or other persons bearing direct liability, may face criminal penalties, including fines and the revocation of pertinent business licenses. Second, given the close ties between private enterprises and their local environments, such incidents can also affect the local government; if the relevant authorities fail in their regulatory duties, they too may incur corresponding liabilities. For instance, in the case involving Shanghai Husi Food Co., Ltd., which was convicted of producing and selling substandard and counterfeit products, the court ultimately imposed a fine of RMB 1.2 million on the company, while its senior executives were each sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment and fined. As a result, Husi Food suffered substantial financial losses and a significant loss of customers, laying off a considerable portion of its workforce. Furthermore, the incident dealt a severe setback to firms throughout the entire supply chain; McDonald’s, for example, saw its sales plummet at one point due to the fallout.
 
  II. Characteristics and Root Causes of Common Official Crimes in Private Enterprises
  Common occupational crimes in China’s private enterprises exhibit both the typical characteristics of criminal offenses and their own distinctive features, which can be broadly categorized as follows:
  (1) Broad Scope of Involvement: Private enterprises have grown rapidly, permeating virtually every sector. They account for a substantial share across industries such as financial investment, energy and mineral resource development and utilization, manufacturing and sales, real estate construction and sales, retail and department stores, grain, oil, and food processing and manufacturing, logistics and transportation, pharmaceuticals and healthcare, electronic information and network services, entertainment, and the catering industry—sectors that also see a high incidence of official‑duty crimes.
  (2) High monetary value of the cases: In cases of official misconduct involving private enterprises, many perpetrators are typically enterprise leaders, senior executives, or financial personnel—individuals who generally exercise control over and manage the organization’s personnel, finances, and funds.
  (3) Diversification of Subjects: The subjects of official misconduct in private enterprises may include corporate legal representatives, directors, managers, and other senior executives, as well as lower-level employees.
  (4) Severe Harmful Consequences: The losses suffered by the victimized entities are often irreparable, and for most private enterprises, the damage caused by official misconduct far outweighs other operational losses.
  (5) Significant Social Impact: A considerable number of private enterprises enjoy high visibility at the provincial, municipal, and even national levels. In today’s information‑rich environment, any instance of illegal or criminal conduct is swiftly brought to the attention of the entire country. This not only tarnishes the enterprise’s reputation but also fosters a negative public perception of the industry, thereby hindering its overall development.
  China’s unique economic system and national conditions have given rise to a diverse array of causes underlying occupational crimes in private enterprises.
  (1) External Factors
  1. Social Causes
  (1) Due to China’s vast territory, there are significant disparities in economic development among provinces, municipalities, and counties. In some cases, local government departments, in order to ensure the stable and rapid growth of their regional economies, adopt measures of local protectionism, turning a blind eye to illegal or non-compliant conduct by local enterprises, or obstructing and creating undue difficulties for law enforcement actions undertaken by out-of‑region judicial authorities.
  (2) At present, the level of social productivity in China is not commensurate with the overall level of social development, resulting in an uneven distribution of economic benefits. Under China’s existing legal system, some individuals, dissatisfied with their share of these benefits, seek to obtain what they desire through illegal means and channels outside the law.
  (3) At present, the rapid development of China’s online information media has led to the swift spread of numerous negative perceptions across regions and industries, easily exerting a subtle yet pervasive influence on corporate strategies and entrepreneurs’ management philosophies. This, in turn, encourages enterprises and business leaders to test the limits of the law, thereby challenging its fundamental boundaries.
  2. Economic Reasons
  Since the 1970s and 1980s, China has implemented a socialist market economy, which has greatly boosted economic development and spurred prosperity across various sectors. However, every bright side inevitably has its shadow. As the market economy has evolved, the system’s shortcomings have gradually come to light; without robust regulations and effective oversight, market disorder can easily arise, prompting enterprises to pursue profit at any cost. This constitutes the first economic factor. The second reason lies in the high degree of freedom inherent in the market economy: since the primary goal of businesses is to maximize profits at the lowest possible cost, some firms, in their quest to stand out in fierce competition, may resort to risky behavior, seeking to undermine the legal framework and engage in criminal activities.
  3. Legal Reasons
  (1) China’s rapid economic growth has propelled the development of its legal system; however, it has also revealed numerous shortcomings and loopholes. These gaps and omissions in laws and regulations have fostered a sense of complacency among some enterprises, prompting them to engage in criminal activities.
  (2) A large number of enterprise‑type crimes have emerged, and the control mechanisms of the judicial authorities are insufficient to address them comprehensively. Moreover, the categories of such offenses are difficult to distinguish, and the boundaries between civil, administrative, and criminal cases remain unclear, leading to frequent conflation.
  (II) Internal Causes
  (1) Enterprises lack a rule-of-law mindset. Employees in private enterprises generally exhibit weak awareness of the rule of law, and companies fail to prioritize providing employees with adequate legal education and outreach. As a result, employees often lack a clear understanding of the boundary between lawful and unlawful conduct, which constitutes a significant internal factor contributing to the frequent occurrence of official‑related crimes in private enterprises.
  (2) The management system has significant vulnerabilities. Many private enterprises have failed to establish a standardized, comprehensive internal management framework; in personnel matters, decision-making often rests with the person in charge, leading to nepotism and weak risk‑prevention awareness.
  (3) The “unwritten rules” of financial management. Some business operators prioritize operational growth while neglecting management systems, particularly in the area of financial administration. In some cases, they lack a comprehensive management framework for the finance department; even when such frameworks exist, they often remain ineffective. This not only increases the risk that certain employees may entertain intentions of committing occupational crimes but also hinders the enterprise’s ability to promptly detect fraudulent activities and complicates efforts to gather evidence.
  (4) Ambiguity of authority and weak enforcement. The absence of a scientifically sound framework for the exercise of power—lacking systematic approaches to the delegation and allocation of authority, the operation of power, and its oversight—results in unclear lines of responsibility and accountability, poor enforcement, opportunities for those seeking personal gain, and risks for the uninformed to cross red lines.
  (5) The distribution of benefits lacks fairness. A fair and reasonable mechanism for benefit allocation is the fundamental prerequisite for preventing criminal activity. As the adage goes, “The concern is not poverty, but inequality”—a principle that applies universally to all enterprises. Establishing a fair and equitable compensation system that ensures a proper match between effort and reward can help curb the subjective intent underlying criminal offenses, thereby helping to prevent such crimes from occurring.
 
  III. The Concept and Characteristics of the Mechanism for the Exercise of Corporate Power
  The mechanism for the exercise of corporate authority is, in essence, the cornerstone of an enterprise’s criminal risk prevention and control system. It constitutes an internal management framework that aligns with the company’s overall operations, ensuring lawful and compliant day-to-day functioning. A scientifically sound and effective mechanism for the exercise of power is the fundamental means of preventing abuses that give rise to criminal offenses. To this end, it is imperative to “establish a mechanism for the exercise of power that features a rational structure, scientific allocation, rigorous procedures, and effective checks and balances, thereby strengthening oversight over power at every stage, from decision-making to implementation,” so as to deprive criminal conduct of any foothold and fundamentally eradicate the conditions that foster such offenses.
  A scientifically sound and well‑structured mechanism for the exercise of corporate authority is generally characterized by its normativity, comprehensiveness, specificity, and timeliness.
  1. Normativity. The mechanism governing the exercise of corporate authority is not only formulated and implemented in accordance with relevant laws and regulations, but also incorporates industry-specific standards or internal corporate policies, which are further refined and adapted to provide both internal and external safeguards for the enterprise’s development.
  2. Comprehensiveness. The corporate governance framework should encompass all legal and regulatory issues that may arise in the course of business operations, covering every aspect of the enterprise and all personnel, thereby providing the most comprehensive regulation and protection for compliant business conduct.
  3. Targeted Approach: Based on the current operational conditions, industry trends, and internal governance frameworks of enterprises across different sectors, regions, and sizes, we develop tailored strategies and plans that address specific needs, ensuring that each company receives the most appropriate policies and approaches for its unique development trajectory. For key areas of management and growth, we systematically strengthen mechanisms for the delegation, allocation, and oversight of authority, while building a corporate criminal risk‑prevention and control framework centered on the core factors essential to an enterprise’s survival and sustainable development.
  4. Timeliness. An enterprise’s governance mechanism should be promptly updated in response to revisions of relevant laws and regulations, as well as the evolving conditions of its geographic location and industry, thereby better safeguarding the company’s long-term development.
  IV. The Significance of a Scientific Corporate Governance Mechanism for Enterprises
  The establishment and refinement of an enterprise’s governance mechanism delineate clear boundaries for its operations, enabling both the organization and its internal stakeholders to grasp the underlying rules of the game. This not only empowers the enterprise to pursue bold growth but also effectively safeguards it from breaching applicable laws and regulations, fostering greater confidence in day-to-day management. Such a framework not only supports the enterprise’s long-term, secure, stable, and rapid development, but also enhances its external competitiveness, strengthens internal cohesion, and reinforces its overall capabilities.
  V. How Can an Enterprise’s Power-Exercise Mechanism Effectively Prevent Corporate Position-Related Crimes?
  Job-related crimes in private enterprises refer to criminal acts committed by personnel of private companies who, taking advantage of their positions, engage in illegal activities or act with gross negligence and fail to perform their duties, thereby disrupting the enterprise’s management order and causing economic losses. The term “position” encompasses the powers and responsibilities entrusted to employees in specific posts, which exist across all areas and departments of the enterprise. Economic disputes—and even criminal offenses—resulting from unreasonable allocation of authority, incomplete exercise of power, and unsystematic oversight are, in fact, not far removed from us:
  Case of a company accountant in Pingdingshan City convicted for maintaining “dual sets of books”: The prosecution alleged that, during his tenure, the accountant, acting on the instructions of the company’s general manager and chief financial officer, established both genuine and falsified corporate accounting records and concealed revenue from core business operations, thereby evading a substantial amount of taxes. Ultimately, the court found the company’s general manager, chief financial officer, and accountant guilty of tax evasion, sentencing each to a term of imprisonment of no less than three years and imposing fines.
  A bribery case involving a surveying and mapping company in Shandong: According to the prosecution, between 2012 and 2014, in order to express gratitude for the assistance provided by a leader of the city’s Bureau of Land and Resources during the bidding process for the rural land registration and certification project—specifically for facilitating coordination and ensuring timely disbursement of project funds—the company’s chairman and the general manager’s assistant repeatedly offered the official a total of RMB 550,000. The court ultimately ruled that the company was guilty of corporate bribery and imposed a fine of RMB 100,000; however, the principal responsible persons and those directly liable were found not guilty. Although the chairman and the general manager’s assistant avoided imprisonment, the company they had established will now be barred from participating in government‑sponsored project bids and may even face challenges to the continued validity of its surveying and mapping qualifications. Such consequences would constitute a devastating blow to both the company and its key executives.
  A smuggling case involving ordinary goods at a Qingdao freight forwarding company: According to the prosecution, during the course of acting as an agent for another company to import waste plastics, the company’s legal representative instructed its employees to fabricate false contracts and invoices—based on genuine documents provided by the client—and submit these falsified materials to the customs brokerage firm. The company then commissioned the brokerage to understate the declared value of the imported waste plastics, thereby evading taxes totaling over RMB 2.78 million. In the first instance, the legal representative was sentenced to 10 years’ imprisonment, and other directly responsible personnel were likewise handed down corresponding penalties. The company was also fined RMB 350,000.
  The occurrence of the criminal offenses described above reflects that, in the course of its business and management, the company has experienced employees’ abuse of authority, unclear allocation of rights and responsibilities, and insufficient control over the exercise of power. It is therefore clear that an incomplete mechanism for the exercise of authority is an important cause of corporate occupational crimes. How, then, should a scientific and comprehensive mechanism for exercising authority be constructed? I believe it should begin with the following approaches:
  The construction of a power‑exercise mechanism should comprise two components: risk assessment and concrete institutional design. The risk assessment must be precise, while the institutional design should be tailored to address specific challenges.
  (1) Risk Prediction
  Based on the market environment, applicable laws and regulations, and the company’s internal operations and human resource management, clearly define the enterprise’s strategic direction and operating context. By drawing on relevant legal provisions and pertinent case law that may be implicated in day-to-day business activities, help the organization establish clear boundaries for its routine operations, implement proactive prevention, forecasting, and risk identification, and maintain vigilant oversight of both corporate performance and the everyday conduct of employees to prevent any deviations from compliance. For identified risks and emerging potential hazards, develop appropriate preventive measures to curb their escalation into legally actionable risks with real‑world consequences.
  (II) Specific Construction
  (1) Grant of Rights
  Authorize the appropriate levels of authority, from senior management to frontline operational units, and standardize the exercise of powers and responsibilities in accordance with actual work requirements. Clearly define and refine key steps within these processes to ensure a clear alignment between authority and accountability, thereby preventing ambiguity or mutual buck-passing. For areas where criminal risks are particularly prevalent in business operations, the enterprise’s decision-making body should grant separate authorization to the relevant departments. Any department or employee that exceeds prescribed limits or deviates from established procedures must be strictly prohibited; moreover, those whose actions increase the likelihood of criminal risk or actually give rise to such risks shall be held explicitly accountable.
  (2) Exercise of Rights
  Within an enterprise, a comprehensive and well‑structured management operating model is established. This model bears a striking resemblance to the human body: the skeletal system and joints serve as central hubs, interconnected yet distinctly delineated by muscles, each performing its own function while coordinating with others and leveraging their strengths to ensure the body’s smooth operation. Accordingly, enterprises can, based on their unique management systems and approaches, establish hierarchical power centers—from top management down to the grassroots level—granting individualized authority to the leaders or departments occupying these centers, clearly defining their respective powers and corresponding responsibilities. Using these power centers as reference points, departmental boundaries are demarcated, and the scope of authority at each level is carefully mapped out, specifying both the extent of managerial and decision‑making prerogatives and the associated liabilities. For areas where the jurisdictions of overlapping power centers intersect, separate authorizations are issued, explicitly defining the respective management and decision‑making powers and accountability within those overlapping zones. Finally, the relevant departments confer necessary delegations of authority to internal staff and clarify their respective responsibilities.
  Once the overall framework has been defined, coordination must be carried out among superiors and subordinates, as well as between peer-level leaders and departments. Senior management should solicit input from each department, convene focused discussions, and sequentially designate the direct supervisors or lead departments for each unit. Unless the matter is of significant importance or essential necessity, multiple layers of direct supervision should be minimized. For peer-level departments, clearly delineate their respective collaborative responsibilities; in cases where disagreements arise, if consultation fails, the issue should be escalated to the respective departments’ direct supervisory authorities for further deliberation. If no resolution can be reached at that level, the matter shall be submitted to the common superior for a final decision.
  Establish daily work logs for each department of the enterprise, with relevant matters signed and filed by the responsible person to facilitate internal oversight. The enterprise’s decision-making bodies and relevant departments shall, in accordance with established procedures, submit materials through hierarchical channels for review and circulation. Materials and reports undergoing circulation must be reviewed promptly and within prescribed timeframes, with responses issued in the shortest possible time. Any omissions or ambiguities shall be promptly communicated and documented, thereby enhancing the efficiency and standardization of internal operations.
  (3) Oversight of Power
  Strengthen internal oversight of corporate power, standardize supervisory criteria, and proactively prevent issues before they arise. Many enterprises maintain inconsistent internal oversight standards, leading to employees’ inadequate understanding of the oversight framework and varying levels of disciplinary action across departments, which in turn fosters indifference toward the company’s management and oversight systems. Enhance communication and coordination among all oversight entities, raise awareness of oversight responsibilities, and reinforce enforcement efforts. Between enterprises, oversight bodies may not operate under a hierarchical superior–subordinate relationship but rather as independent peers; insufficient inter‑departmental dialogue and weak coordination can result in lack of cooperation during multi‑departmental oversight, reduced efficiency, or even mere mutual checks and balances without genuine collaboration. To address this, companies should establish clear, unified oversight frameworks and define consistent oversight content, improve employees’ comprehension of these systems and their scope, and minimize errors arising from ignorance. Develop mechanisms for liaison and cooperation among oversight entities, ensuring that agreed‑upon collaborative tasks are carried out as prescribed. Enterprises may conduct comprehensive quarterly and annual reviews, supplemented by ad hoc spot checks, to bolster the sense of responsibility and preventive awareness among departments and staff. In addition, formulate and refine corresponding reward‑and‑penalty systems: recognize and reward outstanding departments and employees on a quarterly or annual basis, while subjecting underperforming units and individuals to corrective measures and sanctions. Special attention should be given to key functions such as finance and accounting, procurement, and others, with tailored oversight content and incentive‑and‑penalty schemes designed to reflect their specific characteristics.
  The mechanism for the exercise of corporate power is a “rule-of-law system” uniquely tailored to the enterprise itself. Only by identifying the potential risks and vulnerabilities in the course of corporate operations can an organization fully leverage its strengths within the bounds of freedom. The establishment and evolution of such a mechanism can both streamline internal processes and progressively enhance the company’s external competitiveness. As the saying goes, “a head start ensures progress at every step; a delay at the outset sets the pace for all that follows.” In today’s fiercely competitive business environment, it has become imperative to put in place a scientifically sound framework for the governance of corporate power.
  Author Bio:
  Guo Bin is a founding partner and managing director of Shandong Chenggong Law Firm, a member of the Expert Committee of the China Entrepreneur Crime Prevention Research Center at Beijing Normal University, and the Director of the Shandong Center for Criminal Risk Prevention and Control of Chinese Entrepreneurs at Beijing Normal University.
  Wang Yi is the Director of the Criminal Law Committee at Shandong Chenggong Law Firm and a full-time attorney.

Latest News

Post a comment