Legal Risks of Shareholding Nomination and How to Mitigate Them


  Case-Based Legal Analysis: Legal Risks of Shareholding Nomination and How to Mitigate Them
 
  Case Summary:
  On March 1, 2015, Wang Jia (pseudonym) and Wang Yi (pseudonym) entered into a written share‑holding proxy agreement, under which Wang Yi was appointed to hold, on behalf of Wang Jia, a 33% equity interest in a real estate company in Qingdao. On December 23, 2016, Wang Yi died in a traffic accident. Subsequently, Zhao, a creditor of Wang Yi during his lifetime, brought an action before the court, seeking repayment of the outstanding debt from Wang Yi’s wife and son. The court then seized Wang Yi’s 33% equity interest in the Qingdao real estate company and proceeded with compulsory enforcement in accordance with the law.
  This is a typical dispute over share‑holding proxy arrangements in Qingdao. As in the aforementioned case, equity‑holding proxy arrangements often entail certain legal risks in judicial practice. What specific legal risks are involved, and how can they be effectively mitigated?
  Pursuant to Article 25 of the Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the Company Law of the People’s Republic of China (III), anonymous shareholders may face three types of legal risks: first, the creditors of the registered shareholder may seek compulsory enforcement against the registered shareholder’s equity; second, the anonymous shareholder may encounter difficulties in establishing shareholder status and thus be unable to assert their rights against the company; and third, the registered shareholder may maliciously infringe upon the rights and interests of the anonymous shareholder.
  Given that nominee shareholding may entail the aforementioned legal risks, it is advisable for investors to adopt the following targeted measures when entering into a nominee shareholding agreement to mitigate potential legal risks:
  1. It is expressly agreed that the registered shareholder shall exercise shareholder rights in accordance with the wishes of the beneficial shareholder. When exercising rights such as voting, receiving dividends, or exercising pre‑emptive rights to subscribe for additional capital, the registered shareholder must obtain the consent of the beneficial shareholder; otherwise, it shall be liable for any losses incurred as a result.
  2. Clearly exclude the nominee shareholder’s property rights. It shall be expressly agreed that the equity held in trust does not constitute the nominee shareholder’s personal property; accordingly, in the event of the nominee shareholder’s untimely death, divorce, or other such circumstances, the entrusted equity shall not be treated as part of their personal estate and thus cannot be subject to division as either an inheritance or marital property.
  3. The nominee shareholder discloses the equity‑entrustment agreement to the company and the other shareholders, obtains written consent from a majority of the other shareholders authorizing the registered shareholder to “transfer” the equity to the nominee shareholder, and secures a waiver of their preemptive right to purchase.
  4. It is expressly agreed that the nominee shareholder shall establish a pledge over the entrusted equity interests, with the anonymous shareholder as the pledgee, and pledge such equity to the anonymous shareholder.

Latest News

Post a comment