The internet is not a lawless zone; legal persons also enjoy the right to reputation.
Release date:
2019-07-25 09:04
Source:
The internet is not a lawless zone; legal persons also enjoy the right to reputation.
— On a Lawsuit for Infringement of Right of Reputation Filed by a Certain Sanatorium in Qingdao
Jiao Chunyan
A certain sanatorium in Qingdao is a public institution under the provincial federation of trade unions, located at No. 5 Quanzhou Road, Qingdao. Around 2010, in response to urban development needs, the Qingdao Municipal People’s Government placed part of the sanatorium’s land under reserve. In 2012, following the auction of this parcel by the city government, the sanatorium once again made headlines, earning the nickname “land king.” However, the actual party behind the auction was the Qingdao Municipal People’s Government, with no connection to the sanatorium; linking the sanatorium to the “land king” designation constitutes a misinterpretation of the news.
In late April 2013, several exposé posts suddenly appeared on major portal websites. The authors alleged that a land auction at a certain sanatorium in Qingdao was riddled with corruption, accusing the institution’s leadership of embezzlement and misappropriation of state‑owned assets. Fueled by one‑sided resentment toward officials and the wealthy, these posts quickly became viral sensations, dominating the homepages of leading portals. Many uninformed netizens also jumped in, clamoring for harsh punishment and calling for decisive action.
A certain sanatorium in Qingdao, left with no way to defend itself and utterly confused, turned to Shandong Chenggong Law Firm for legal advice. As the sanatorium’s long-term legal counsel, Chenggong promptly responded by establishing a legal service team led by Chief Attorney Guo Bin, Attorney Jiao Chunyan, and others. In response to the overwhelming wave of exposé posts circulating online, the team formulated a detailed action plan aimed at safeguarding its rights in accordance with the law, swiftly mitigating the adverse impact, and promptly restoring its reputation.
Step one: securing the evidence. In cases of virtualized online infringement, gathering and preserving evidence presents a significant challenge, and the success of this process directly determines the outcome of the entire case. Accordingly, we prioritized the systematic collection and preservation of evidence related to the infringing conduct. Under the law, for online infringement, we could petition the court to order evidence preservation. However, court‑ordered preservation is time‑consuming; each additional day a post remains online increases the harm inflicted on a certain sanatorium in Qingdao. For this reason, we abandoned that route and instead engaged with the Qingdao Notary Office, opting to have the evidence notarized and preserved. We thoroughly explained the urgency of this case to the Qingdao Notary Office and secured its fullest possible support, successfully preserving all relevant evidence in just one day.
Step two: Issue a legal letter demanding the removal of the infringing posts. While preserving evidence of the infringing posts at a notary office, we also drafted the legal letter. We addressed every website that had published the posts, and in the letter we took a very firm stance: upon receipt, the websites were required to immediately and unconditionally delete the offending content. According to our records, more than a dozen websites that received our legal letters removed the infringing posts within one to two business days of receiving them. The deletion of the posts effectively brought the infringement to an end. However, the rights‑protection efforts of a certain sanatorium in Qingdao have only just begun; if we fail to restore the sanatorium’s reputation and mitigate the negative impact of those posts, then our legal work will amount to little more than scratching an itch—utterly ineffective.
Step three: File a lawsuit for infringement of the right to reputation in accordance with the law. If securing evidence of the infringing conduct and compelling the cessation of such conduct constitute our defensive strategy, then it is now time for the Qingdao sanatorium to launch a full‑scale counterattack. Relying on the grounds of infringement of the right to reputation, we filed a civil action with the People’s Court, demanding that the infringer publicly publish a notice to clarify the facts, acknowledge its wrongdoing, and offer an apology. During the proceedings, as counsel, we submitted to the court a comprehensive array of evidence related to the disputed post, demonstrating that the content of the post was seriously factually inaccurate and had severely damaged the reputation of the Qingdao sanatorium. Ultimately, the People’s Court duly found the infringement to be established and ordered the infringer to issue a public apology to the Qingdao sanatorium through a newspaper.
Step four: Initiate enforcement proceedings. Although the case was won, the lawyer’s representation did not end there. For a certain sanatorium in Qingdao, a court judgment alone cannot restore its reputation or adequately mitigate the adverse impact; only a public apology published through official media can clear the sanatorium’s name, set the record straight, and promptly inform the public—many of whom remain unaware of the facts—that the content of the online post was entirely fabricated. Accordingly, following the judgment’s entry into force, the counsel promptly filed an application for compulsory enforcement with the People’s Court.
Looking back at this case, from the very outset of our engagement through to the subsequent enforcement proceedings, our representation was meticulously coordinated and conducted in strict accordance with established procedures, with each step executed firmly and steadily. The key to this success lay in rigorous standardization—both in the practice of law and in the management of case‑handling processes—both of which are encapsulated within this matter. Many young lawyers may wonder: how exactly can one achieve such standardization? In my view, the answer is the “Chenggong Handbook.” This single volume distills the collective efforts of generations of Chenggong practitioners; it embodies nearly two decades of wisdom and serves as an indispensable guide for young lawyers seeking to establish standardized professional practices. For junior attorneys, pondering what “standardization” means may be abstract and theoretical, whereas following the provisions of the “Chenggong Handbook” is the pragmatic path forward.
Latest News
Post a comment