On the Fifth Key to Law-Based Administration


  On the “Five Locks” of Law-Based Administration
 
  “When laws and regulations are enforced, the country is well-governed; when they are lax, the country falls into chaos.” In today’s era of comprehensively advancing law-based governance, only by setting an example—ensuring that all laws are observed and strictly enforced—can the state achieve orderly development within the framework of the rule of law, and can the people reap greater benefits. To administer in accordance with the law, it is essential to focus on five key elements—purpose, legal basis, procedures, methods, and outcomes—and to establish a comprehensive, multi-dimensional system of checks and balances on the exercise of power, ensuring that administrative authority operates within the bounds of the law and wields the law as a tool for good governance.
 
  I. Locking onto the Goal: Law Enforcement for the People
  For the government to administer in accordance with the law, it must first clearly define and lock in the purpose of its administrative actions. This is because the purpose directly determines both the legality of the administrative act itself and the extent to which its outcomes are accepted by the public. If the very purpose of an administrative action is hypocritical, the social effects it can produce are readily foreseeable; such an action, which fails to gain public acceptance, loses all raison d’être. From a legal perspective, an administrative act that is formally lawful but substantively unlawful will not be accorded legal validity and may ultimately be deemed invalid or even constitute a criminal offense. Accordingly, the purpose of administrative action stands as the primary consideration in the government’s exercise of lawful administration.
  To determine the purpose of an administrative act, one must first identify all possible objectives it may entail—ranging from legal aims to other considerations—and then use the specific facts of the case to ascertain the act’s true intent. In summary, administrative acts with improper purposes fall into two categories: first, deviation—where the act ostensibly complies with the law but in reality pursues unlawful interests; such cases often involve seeking economic gain. Second, misalignment—where the stated objective serves the public interest but fails to conform to the intended purpose of the relevant statute; sometimes, what appears to be compliance with one law is, in fact, aimed at achieving a different legal objective. As the fundamental principle governing the allocation and exercise of governmental power, rule‑by‑law seeks to build a government under the rule of law. However, in practice, this approach may confront competing and conflicting value frameworks—such as managerialism, checks‑and‑balances theory, balancing theory, and public‑interest centrism—and, in particular, “interest‑driven administration,” which prioritizes the self‑interests of public officials, accounts for a substantial share.
  From the perspective of the very essence of administration according to law, its core lies in supervising and regulating administrative power, thereby safeguarding and upholding the legitimate rights and interests of citizens. The key to such administration is to govern officials in accordance with the law, rather than to govern the people; it is to regulate power by law, rather than to manage affairs by law. Consequently, as reforms toward a law-based government deepen, administration according to law will serve as an institutional guarantee for serving the people in China’s new era. Administrative enforcement accounts for more than 80 percent of all legal application in our country, making it the most crucial dimension of governing the nation by law—and also the sphere most closely connected with the general public. Effectively implementing the principle of serving the people in the administrative domain means realizing that very principle. Administration according to law must remain firmly committed to the goal of serving the people and establish a rigorous mechanism grounded in the guiding principle of “serving the people.” Laws alone cannot enforce themselves; their implementation inevitably encounters a variety of practical challenges. Under such circumstances, steadfastly anchoring oneself to the objective and ethos of “enforcing the law for the people” constitutes the very soul of administration according to law.
 
  II. Legal Basis of the Order: Sufficient Facts and Legal Grounds
  For the government to administer in accordance with the law, it must establish a solid factual and legal foundation. An administrative act lacking sufficient grounds is like a seemingly flawless structure that lacks a stable foundation and structural support—utterly untenable and unable to withstand scrutiny. Whether an administrative act rests on adequate factual and legal bases is therefore a key issue that must be rigorously substantiated in the context of lawful administration.
  Ascertaining the facts is a prerequisite for applying the law and constitutes the ultimate foundation upon which administrative agencies base their administrative decisions. Accurate fact-finding first depends on the discovery of facts—namely, the identification of information indicating unlawful conduct within the factual circumstances of everyday life. Second comes the clarification of facts: once an administrative agency has identified evidence of unlawful conduct, it must further establish the specific details of the case. Finally, there is the proof of facts, which encompasses both substantive and procedural facts. In administrative enforcement, the primary purpose of fact-finding by administrative authorities is to determine whether a particular factual issue exists and, accordingly, to render a decision or take appropriate action; by contrast, the main aim of proving the facts is to prevent administrative disputes by securing, in advance, the factual basis necessary to ensure the legality of administrative actions. Evidence serves as the crucial factual support for the legality of administrative acts; thus, the application by administrative agencies of established rules of evidence to obtain sufficient and lawful factual grounds is a fundamental precondition for lawful administration. So how should the criteria of “sufficient evidence” and “insufficient principal evidence,” as stipulated in Articles 69 and 70 of the Administrative Litigation Law, be construed? China’s Administrative Litigation Law does not explicitly specify whether administrative litigation should be subject to legal review or factual review. In judicial practice, China adopts a modulated approach that combines legal review with a limited degree of factual review. This mode of review differs from the Anglo‑American system, which fully defers to the administrative authority’s discretion, and also contrasts with certain jurisdictions that undertake a comprehensive review of administrative acts. It may be summarized under four observations: First, assess whether the central issue in the administrative dispute concerns a question of law or a question of fact; if the dispute hinges on a legal issue, factual matters are generally not re-examined. Second, distinguish between permissive administrative acts and those imposing obligations; where an administrative act is of a permissive nature and its legality depends on whether the plaintiff’s application meets statutory requirements, a certain degree of factual scrutiny may still be warranted. Third, evaluate the extent to which the administrative act affects the rights and interests of the administrative counterpart; if the impact is substantial, clarifying the true state of the administrative legal relationship may necessitate a limited factual review. Fourth, consider the specialized or technical nature of the administrative act; when the matter involves highly specialized or technical issues, the administrative authority’s assessment of the relevant facts should be accorded due respect.
  In the ideal state of law-based administration, the government would regulate administrative conduct in accordance with national laws, thereby ensuring the supremacy of law over administrative action. However, in the practical implementation of law-based administration, local legislation and normative documents that contravene higher‑level laws, as well as documents issued by Party organizations at various levels and the personal will of individual leaders, are more likely to serve as the basis for administrative decision‑making. Consequently, it is essential to clearly distinguish between the “law” underlying the principle of law-based administration and the “law” that constitutes the sources of administrative law, confining the legal foundation of law-based administration strictly to statutes enacted by the National People’s Congress and its Standing Committee, and refraining from any arbitrary expansive interpretations.
 
  III. Locking Process: Emphasizing Procedures and Details
  Determining whether the sequence and steps of administrative actions are correct and lawful is also a crucial component of law-based administration. In general, as long as the intended objectives are achieved, the specific order or procedures employed—so long as they remain within the bounds of the law—are of little consequence. However, in the course of governmental administration, administrative acts must adhere to a series of procedural requirements, including legally prescribed steps, methods, and workflows; failure to do so constitutes a violation of the law and may undermine the attainment of the desired social outcomes. Over the past two decades and more, China’s reforms—aimed at economic marketization and political democratization—have significantly advanced the rule of law in administration. Throughout this institutional transformation, administrative procedure, as a core element of administrative rule of law, has undergone substantial development. Nevertheless, in practice, an often‑overlooked impediment to law-based administration is the inadequacy of administrative procedures. Some scholars contend that the emergence of an administrative procedure law in any country hinges on three fundamental prerequisites: the institutional restraint of administrative power, the procedural legitimacy of litigation, and the detailed articulation of rights claims. Accordingly, law-based administration must place particular emphasis on the procedural framework and the meticulous attention to detail in administrative actions.
  As a normative mechanism that governs the exercise of administrative power, administrative procedure serves both to prevent the abuse of such power through negative checks and to foster the formation of the public will by facilitating its proactive implementation. Although the current fragmented, sector‑specific legislative model for administrative procedures still faces numerous challenges, it has nonetheless played a significant and constructive role in regulating administrative authority and safeguarding citizens’ rights to information and participation. Moving forward, the focus of building a law‑based government should shift toward further refining and improving the administrative procedural framework.
  Currently, the approach to building a law-based government suffers from structural shortcomings: it places excessive emphasis on internal mechanisms while neglecting external ones; prioritizes substantive authority‑setting mechanisms over procedural‑norm‑setting ones; and favors post‑event remedies and accountability mechanisms at the expense of process‑oriented regulatory frameworks. As a result, it fails to impose effective normative checks and restraints on administrative power. For instance, in cases of the compulsory demolition of illegal structures, strict adherence to the procedural requirements set forth in the Administrative Compulsion Law is essential. Prior to demolition, the party concerned must first be notified to carry out the removal themselves; public notices must be posted locally, and demolition may not take place at night—otherwise, the action itself would be deemed unlawful. Similarly, during the course of compulsory demolition, if procedural violations by the administrative agency render it difficult for the affected party to furnish sufficient evidence of their damages, or even prevent them from providing any evidence at all, the courts will apply a reduced burden of proof on the administrative counterpart, thereby upholding the legislative spirit of safeguarding the legitimate rights and interests of those subject to administrative action. Furthermore, when taking photographs as evidence at the enforcement site, the principle should be to proceed from the overall scene to the specific details: capture comprehensive overview shots, central‑area photographs, and close‑up images. The overview photograph establishes the natural spatial context of the site; the central‑area photograph presents a holistic view of the focal zone under inspection, typically comprising several frames that, through varying angles, collectively convey the full picture of the scene; and the close‑up photographs document the original condition of the objects involved, the characteristics of relevant evidence, as well as the procedures for collecting such evidence, sealing off the items in question, and conducting sampling and sealing. Only when these three categories of photographs are taken together can the circumstances of the on‑site inspection be fully and accurately reflected. Great principles do not overlook minor details; it is precisely the attention to procedural rigor and meticulousness that ensures the fundamental integrity of law‑based administration.
 
  IV. Locking Procedures: Legal, Reasonable, Convenient, and Efficient
  In the course of carrying out specific administrative actions, what is closest to the realities of grassroots work—and yet most easily overlooked—is the concrete measures and methods employed. To achieve their intended objectives, administrative agencies may adopt a variety of approaches and measures within the bounds of the law; in such cases, it is essential to determine which methods are both lawful and reasonable, and which best serve the public in a convenient, efficient manner.
  In the course of administrative law enforcement, it is essential to clearly distinguish between different measures and methods and to identify their respective applicable contexts. Take, for example, the distinction between preliminary registration and preservation on the one hand, and seizure and impoundment on the other: preliminary registration and preservation constitutes an evidentiary procedural rule within the administrative enforcement process, whereas seizure and impoundment are independent administrative coercive measures applied during that process. The purpose of preliminary registration and preservation is to safeguard evidence in a case; it must be employed when such evidence may be lost or become difficult to obtain later, serving as a means of collecting evidence in administrative enforcement without fully restricting the party’s use of the relevant items. Consequently, the party cannot invoke this measure to file an administrative reconsideration or bring an administrative lawsuit. By contrast, the purpose of seizure and impoundment is to control objects so as to deter unlawful conduct, prevent unlawful infringement, and mitigate imminent dangers. Although it also serves to preserve enforcement‑related evidence, this is not its primary or exclusive objective. Such measures temporarily restrict the party’s ability to use or dispose of the seized property and constitute an independent specific administrative act, the legal consequences of which are subject to judicial review—enabling the filing of administrative reconsideration or administrative litigation. The adoption of these two distinct enforcement approaches will yield different legal outcomes; therefore, they must be carefully differentiated and accurately selected during the enforcement process.
  Moreover, in recent years, as the objects of law enforcement and the enforcement environment have continued to evolve, the methods employed by enforcement authorities have undergone significant changes. For instance, certain administrative agencies have abused inducement‑based enforcement practices, arousing public resentment, tarnishing the government’s image and undermining social norms, and giving rise to new social tensions and a moral crisis—while also further eroding the fairness and justice of the law and the authority of the rule of law. Consequently, administrative agencies and their staff must, when carrying out administrative law enforcement, strictly adhere to the legally prescribed purposes, procedures, means, and methods. They should attach great importance, both ideologically and practically, to the risks inherent in administrative enforcement, resolutely rectify the tendency among some enforcers to be “careless” beforehand, “sloppy” during enforcement, and “hesitant” afterward, and effectively safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of the parties subject to administrative action. In doing so, they should strive to administer in accordance with the law and proactively prevent and resolve administrative enforcement risks.
 
  V. The Outcome of Enforcement: The Unity of Legal and Social Effects
  Ultimately, the key consideration in law-based administration is whether an administrative act will give rise to adverse consequences and whether it can achieve a harmonious balance between legal and social outcomes. Even if the purpose of the administrative act has been clearly defined, its legal basis has been established, and its procedures and methods are legally sound, if the resulting effects contravene the expectations set forth by law, such consequences will fundamentally alter the characterization of the entire administrative act. Therefore, prior to implementing an administrative act, it is imperative to assess whether it may produce undesirable outcomes.
  Achieving an organic unity between the legal and social outcomes of administrative law enforcement is both a key objective of standardizing administrative enforcement and an effective means of enhancing the credibility of administrative enforcement agencies. Some administrative law enforcement officers interpret and apply the law in a rigid, dogmatic manner, treating statutes and regulations as immutable or as containing a single, definitive answer, thereby engaging in mechanical enforcement. They believe this approach safeguards the dignity and authority of the law, yet it often results in a disconnect between legal outcomes and social realities. Alternatively, there are those who disregard the fundamental requirements of laws and regulations, prioritizing social effects over legal ones—sometimes even flouting statutory provisions to serve local or institutional interests, thus undermining the principles and authority of the rule of law and reducing laws and regulations to mere instruments for accommodating immediate needs or the preferences of particular individuals. At the root of these problems lies a mindset among enforcement agencies and personnel that views themselves as masters of the people, equating governance with enforcement, enforcement with punishment, and punishment with fines. In practice, even when cases clearly involve wrongdoing, enforcement authorities are reluctant to correct their course; and when no legal provision exists, they nonetheless impose obligations on parties in violation of the law.
  The prestige of administrative agencies should be built on impartial law enforcement, not on the exercise of coercive power. The authority of administrative law enforcement is reflected not only in the agency’s ability to achieve legislative objectives through the implementation of laws, but also in its capacity to garner favorable social recognition and influence by delivering tangible legal outcomes, thereby advancing the goal of transitioning social governance toward the rule of law. Consequently, the ultimate focus of lawful administration must be the outcomes of administrative actions, which should serve to guide the public in upholding the rule of law and to reinforce the authority and credibility of administrative law enforcement.

Latest News

Post a comment