Zhou Enlai and the System of Confidentiality


Zhou Enlai and the System of Confidentiality

 

Zhou Enlai devoted his entire life to the cause of the Party and the people, tirelessly dedicating himself to their service. Throughout his career, he maintained a rigorous, conscientious, and meticulous work style. Whether during the revolutionary struggle or in the period of socialist construction, he attached great importance to the formulation and implementation of various systems and regulations. Here, the author shares several related anecdotes recorded during interviews.

 

“This restaurant is too close to our lodging, which makes it difficult to maintain confidentiality.”

 

In 1997, led by Comrade Zheng Shuyun—Zhou Enlai’s personal nurse and then recently retired from the Central Documentation Research Office—the author paid a visit in Beijing to Huang Jieran and his wife, Yang Qinglan. This revolutionary couple had both once engaged in revolutionary activities in Shanghai under the auspices of the CPC Central Committee. When Zhou Enlai served as Minister of the Organization Department of the CPC Central Committee, Huang Jieran was his secretary, while Yang Qinglan acted as an internal courier for Deng Yingchao during her tenure at the Central Women’s Committee.

 

That year Ninety-two-year-old Mr. Huang told me: Zhou Enlai led the underground struggle in Shanghai for several years, and the secret agents tried every possible means to capture him but never succeeded. The reason was that he adhered to a strict routine of staying hidden by day and emerging at night—never going out before 9 p.m. and always returning to his lodgings before 5 a.m. There was only one exception: when Ren Bishi was arrested in Shanghai, the enemy did not yet know his true identity. Zhou Enlai instructed the red operative Huang Mulan to carry out a rescue operation. Since the mission required funds, Zhou had no choice but to disguise himself as a rickshaw driver on the Shanghai streets and, in an unusual move, venture out in broad daylight to borrow money from Yang Du, one of the “Six Gentlemen” of the Chuan’an Association. (At that time, Yang Du had already been admitted to the Communist Party of China through Zhou’s introduction.) As he hurried back on his rickshaw after securing the loan, he saw a car coming out of the French Concession strike and knock down a worker who was walking along the road as usual. The blame clearly lay with the driver, yet instead of upholding the law impartially, the police officers unjustly accused the victim. Seeing this, Zhou was furious; he felt like stepping forward to speak a word of justice and teach those foreigners and the policemen a lesson. But then he reconsidered: if he did so, not only would the rescue of Ren Bishi be doomed, but he might even expose himself—and that would be a grave loss for our Party. So he swallowed his anger and pedaled away from the scene.

 

After working together for a long time in the central government organs, Huang Jieran and Yang Qinglan developed feelings for one another. With Zhou Enlai’s approval, they decided to get married. Huang Jieran believed that marriage was a momentous occasion in life and wanted to hold a simple yet festive wedding. He even rented a small restaurant, planning to invite everyone to gather on their wedding day and share a few cups of celebratory wine. To avoid attracting the attention of secret agents, he had previously arranged with the restaurant management to schedule the banquet for the evening. It did not begin until after nine o’clock. However, when he had everything in place and reported to Zhou Enlai, the latter pondered at length and ultimately did not approve of Huang Jieran’s plan. He told Huang Jieran, “This restaurant is too close to our lodging; it would compromise security. We cannot afford to violate the confidentiality regulations.” Accordingly, he instructed Huang Jieran to cancel the rented venue and compensate the restaurant for its losses. Huang Jieran and Yang Qinglan then quietly held a very simple wedding ceremony at their secret residence in Shanghai.

 

“He shouldn’t have shown you such confidential documents!”

 

Zhou Enlai had a great-nephew named Zhou Guozhen, who was a renowned mathematics educator. He was older than the author. At the age of four, he was also the author’s close friend. In 1951, Zhou Songyao, Premier Zhou Enlai’s sixth uncle and a juren of the late Qing dynasty, was appointed as one of the first members of the Central Institute for Cultural and Historical Research. That same year, his only son, Zhou Enkui, tragically passed away. Recognizing that his uncle must be deeply grieved and tormented by the loss of his child in old age, Zhou Enlai specially brought Zhou Guozhen, Zhou Songyao’s beloved great-grandson, to Beijing to keep him company. After arriving in the capital, Zhou Guozhen enrolled in secondary school; initially, all his living expenses and tuition were covered by Zhou Enlai. Later, after beginning his career, Zhou Guozhen fell in love—his girlfriend was the daughter of a senior leader in the Wuhan Military Region.

 

Once, Zhou Guozhen went to Wuhan to meet his girlfriend. Knowing in advance that his future son-in-law was a great-nephew of Zhou Enlai, her father, during their conversation, freely showed him several central documents for him to peruse. Among these documents were those pertaining to the Central Committee’s Conference of Seven Thousand, as well as others on various topics; one of them concerned the establishment by the Central Committee of a committee composed of… A special committee of the CPC Central Committee, composed of 27 members and chaired by Zhou Enlai, was tasked with developing the “Two Bombs and One Satellite” program—namely, the atomic bomb, the hydrogen bomb, and an artificial satellite. Upon seeing this, Zhou Guozhen was overjoyed. After returning to Beijing, he once met Zhou Enlai and, unable to contain his excitement, blurted out: “Seventh Uncle, our country is going to build atomic and hydrogen bombs too? That’s simply wonderful!” But upon hearing this, Zhou Enlai immediately frowned deeply and asked sternly, “How did you come to know about this? Who told you?” “I saw the document,” Zhou Guozhen replied, still unable to suppress the thrill and joy in his heart. “And where did you see it?” It was only then that Zhou Guozhen noticed his seventh uncle’s expression had grown very grave—clearly displeased—and so he dutifully recounted what had happened. Zhou Enlai was furious. “How could he possibly show you such a document? This document was circulated only to provincial‑level military units; even now, it hasn’t reached the county‑ or regimental‑level. He should never have let you see such classified material!”

 

At the time, Xu Ming, deputy director of the Premier’s Office, happened to be present and stepped in to smooth things over, saying to Zhou Guozhen: “Premier, Guozhen will not leak,” Zhou Enlai replied. “This is not a matter of whether it gets leaked or not; it concerns whether the confidentiality system can be effectively implemented and enforced—this is a question of organizational discipline.”

 

Later, Zhou Enlai also criticized, at a relevant central-level meeting, the leading comrade who had shown the document to Zhou Guozhen, urging all comrades to take this as a cautionary lesson and to ensure strict compliance with the Party’s confidentiality regulations.

 

“What’s the wrong direction? Who told you that?”

 

In the autumn of 1997, when the author traveled to Beijing to visit Qiao Jinwang, a former bodyguard of Zhou Enlai, Qiao recalled with deep emotion that, as the country was preparing for its first hydrogen‑bomb test, meteorological monitoring indicated an unusual westerly wind over Lop Nur in Xinjiang. This meant that, following the explosion, vast amounts of radioactive debris and fallout would be carried by the wind toward the densely populated eastern regions, posing a serious threat to public health. Consequently, Zhou Enlai declined to authorize the detonation.

 

That night, Zhou Enlai could not sleep. By dawn, though he should have retired to rest, he remained vigilantly at the telephone, waiting with undiminished alertness for the wind to shift. Seeing that Zhou Enlai had been working continuously for seventeen or eighteen hours, Deng Yingchao felt deeply concerned and went over to the guard’s duty room outside the Premier’s office, where she asked Qiao Jinwang, who was on duty: “Old Qiao, my spouse has been working for nearly twenty hours already—why aren’t they heading to bed to rest yet?” Qiao Jinwang replied in a low voice, “I heard the wind direction’s unfavorable, so the experiment can’t go ahead.”

 

Deng Yingchao was concerned about Premier Zhou’s health—how could he possibly endure such relentless work? So she turned and walked into the Premier’s office, where Zhou Enlai was at his desk, and said to him: “Enlai, I hear the winds are blowing in the wrong direction—why don’t you take a rest for now? The wind will turn one day, won’t it?”

 

A casual remark by Deng Yingchao, however, instantly enraged Zhou Enlai. He raised his head and sternly rebuked Deng Yingchao: “What’s the problem? Who told you that?” Deng Yingchao hadn’t expected Zhou Enlai to lose his temper with her, so she replied truthfully, “Old Qiao just said it a moment ago.” “Bring Old Qiao in here,” Zhou Enlai said, his expression still grave.

 

It turned out that Zhou Enlai had strict confidentiality requirements for the staff at Xihuating: they were not to ask questions they should not, nor to speak about matters they should not; and even if someone else inquired about information he himself knew, he was forbidden to disclose it. Accordingly, after Qiao Jinwang approached Zhou Enlai’s desk, the Premier said to him in a serious tone: “Old Qiao, I am a member of the Politburo Standing Committee, and Sister Xiao Chao is a member of the Central Committee. She works on women’s affairs; her work has nothing to do with the ‘Two Bombs and One Satellite’ program. Therefore, I did not discuss this matter with her, nor was she permitted to read or inquire about the documents I brought back. This is a matter of discipline and of adhering to established procedures.” Knowing he had erred, Qiao Jinwang offered a thorough self-criticism to Zhou Enlai.

 

Zhou Enlai was never lax in upholding any of the secrecy regulations and resolutely safeguarded and enforced them.

Latest News

Post a comment