Upholding principles while innovating—collective wisdom is powerful: Lei Heping’s inheritance dispute


  Uphold the right path while innovating; collective wisdom is powerful.
  
— A Record of the Lei Heping Inheritance Dispute Case
  Jiao Chunyan
 
  Lei Heping’s husband passed away in 2012 due to illness. At the time of his death, he left no will but did leave an estate valued at nearly 30 million yuan. It was this substantial inheritance that sparked a bitter legal battle over the estate between his wife and daughter on one side, and his parents-in-law on the other. Shortly after Lei Heping’s husband died, her in-laws—two elderly individuals both over ninety years old—filed a lawsuit with the People’s Court, bringing their daughter-in-law and granddaughter before the court and seeking a lawful division of the estate. The bulk of the estate consisted of real property: seven residential units in total, two located in Qingdao and five in Shenzhen. Among these seven properties, the apartment at Hisense Yandao International on Macau Road in Qingdao became the central point of contention. The in-laws, as plaintiffs, requested that the court rule in their favor, awarding them ownership of that particular unit, while the daughter-in-law and granddaughter, as defendants, also sought to claim it. In the first-instance ruling, the Qingdao Intermediate People’s Court awarded the apartment to the in-laws; dissatisfied with this decision, Lei Heping appealed to the Shandong Provincial Higher People’s Court. After reviewing the case, the Shandong Provincial Higher People’s Court found that the original trial had followed improper procedural rules and, in accordance with the law, remanded the case for retrial.
  During the retrial phase, Lei Heping, having heard of our firm’s reputation, sought out Chenggong Law Firm, hoping we would represent her in this case. Following an internal review, we determined that the case involved a substantial sum of money, with sharply heightened tensions between the parties and significant disputes. However, as the surviving spouse, Lei Heping’s views should be given due weight—particularly with respect to the allocation of assets in kind—and such distribution should prioritize practical considerations that facilitate production and daily life. After deliberation by the firm, we decided to take on the representation. This case subsequently became the largest estate‑inheritance matter in Chenggong Law Firm’s history in terms of the value at stake.
  Upon accepting the mandate, our legal team first visited the Qingdao Intermediate People’s Court to review the first-instance case file, gaining a comprehensive understanding of the trial proceedings. We then convened multiple case‑review meetings. During these sessions, we recognized that simply seeking to award the Haixin Yandao International property to Lei Heping on the grounds that it would better serve his livelihood would not withstand the judge’s discretionary authority. Given that the plaintiffs are the decedent’s parents, both over ninety years old and long‑time residents of Qingdao, it would be entirely understandable if the court were to rule in their favor for this reason. To ensure that Lei Heping’s claims received the fullest possible judicial support, we meticulously examined the facts, scrutinized relevant statutory provisions, and challenged conventional notions of inheritance. We advanced the proposition that the property interests of co‑owners should be afforded priority protection. Although no one had previously raised such an argument in inheritance cases, after thorough deliberation we concluded that it was legally grounded and merited the court’s endorsement. Representing clients in litigation often requires us to stand by our own judgment; we cannot simply adhere to established practice merely because no one has done so before. As it turned out, this particular argument became the focal point of the trial and the most compelling rationale we used to persuade the judge.
  Regarding this case, we have two key takeaways: First, the power of a team is boundless. When the client first came to our firm to hear our litigation strategy, six of our lawyers sat in a row across from them, each fulfilling their role: Attorney Jiao Chunyan presented the PowerPoint, while Attorney Hu Xiaoli operated the computer, making the entire case‑handling approach crystal clear. After hearing the plan, the client said something that has stayed with me ever since: “Attorney Jiao, I hired a lawyer in Shenzhen for the first instance, but I’ve never seen a firm like Chenggong handle a case this way. Your professionalism truly impressed me.” Perhaps it was precisely this spirit that led the client to sign a retainer agreement with us without hesitation. This is the compelling force of teamwork. When those six lawyers sat together before the client, they conveyed the collective strength and formidable synergy of Chenggong Law Firm. Second, the power of expertise. This case is a quintessential example of combining conventional wisdom with innovative thinking. While adhering to the traditional approach in inheritance matters, we pioneered the principle of prioritizing the protection of co‑owners’ share interests, catching the opposing counsel off guard and challenging the judge’s established line of reasoning. As a result, the judge was compelled to reconsider our arguments with renewed care and deliberation. Such innovation in legal practice requires a robust professional foundation and solid theoretical underpinnings. In line with our firm’s advocacy for the “five‑fold path” of legal practice—standardization, professionalism, specialization, internationalization, and digitalization—I believe that once a lawyer transitions from standardization to professionalization, they have acquired the basic skills necessary to make a living. However, mere standardization and professionalization are insufficient for true growth; to become a distinguished senior lawyer, one must pursue a path of specialization.

Latest News

Post a comment