Layoffs are very “brutal,” and the consequences are severe.


  Layoffs are very “brutal,” and the consequences are severe.
  Ren Li
 
  Recently, online reports have surfaced alleging that a certain used-car trading platform has been closing numerous brick-and-mortar stores across multiple cities, leaving employees with two options: either resign voluntarily—with no severance pay—or first resign voluntarily (also without compensation) and then pay 40,000 yuan out of pocket to become a “partner” of the platform. Many employees have already filed labor arbitration cases in their respective localities. For a time, news of the company’s bankruptcy set social media ablaze; the company subsequently issued a statement denying the claims, asserting that there had been no forced layoffs or bankruptcy, but rather a shift to a new business model that would provide dedicated funding support to partners, among other measures.
  Regardless of whether the reports of “violent layoffs” are true or false, if an employer requires—or even forces—an employee to terminate the labor contract by means of a “voluntary resignation,” such practice is clearly unlawful and may entail serious consequences. The termination or dissolution of a labor contract must comply with applicable laws; employers may not act arbitrarily, or they will be held legally liable for unlawful termination or dissolution.
  Chapter IV of China’s Labor Contract Law sets forth clear provisions regarding the circumstances under which a labor contract may be terminated or come to an end. Moreover, Article 13 of the Implementing Regulations of the Labor Contract Law expressly stipulates that employers may not stipulate any termination conditions other than those enumerated in Article 44 of the Labor Contract Law.
  Whether viewed from the social‑law nature of the Labor Contract Law or from Article 19 of the Implementing Regulations of the Labor Contract Law—which lists only fourteen circumstances under which an employer may terminate labor contracts with fixed-term, indefinite-term, or task‑based terms, without providing any additional discretionary provisions—current Chinese legislation has yet to confer upon both parties the right to agree on the termination of a labor contract.
  Regardless of whether an enterprise is undergoing strategic transformation, business restructuring, facing operational difficulties, experiencing a cash-flow crisis, or encountering other circumstances that render continued employment untenable, any termination or dissolution of employment contracts must be handled through mutually agreed‑upon negotiations.
  Equal consultation is a fundamental right granted to workers by law, and the provisions of the Labor Law and related regulations likewise reflect protection of this basic right. Employers should fully recognize and understand this principle, particularly when terminating or ending labor contracts—matters that directly affect workers’ rights and interests. Equal consultation entails respect and candor; employers should clearly explain the necessity for such termination or dissolution and propose a reasonable compensation package. Even the most intransigent parties can appreciate that reaching a mutually agreed settlement with timely, appropriate compensation is far preferable to facing difficulties in enforcing a single arbitration award followed by two levels of litigation.
  If both parties reach a mutual agreement, they should promptly execute a written agreement to terminate or rescind the labor contract, specifying the facts underlying the termination or rescission, the corresponding compensation plan, and the rights and obligations of each party, so as to ensure smooth implementation. With respect to agreements voluntarily entered into, provided there are no circumstances such as unlawful content, material misrepresentation, or manifest unfairness, any subsequent withdrawal by a party will likely not be upheld.

Latest News

Post a comment