Chenggong—Trusted and Reliable! Attorneys Liu Cui and Rong Qiumin have received a letter of gratitude and a banner from their client.


 
On April 6, 2022, the client, Ms. Liu, made a special trip to Shandong Chenggong Law Firm to present two banners—one inscribed with “Virtue and Erudition, Dedication and Professionalism, Legal Elite, Model Lawyer”—and the other with “Master of the Law, Skilled in Practice, Diligent and Responsible, Alleviating People’s Concerns”—to Partner Liu Cui and Attorney Rong Qiumin, respectively. She also personally penned a letter of gratitude to the firm, expressing her appreciation for the professional competence and meticulous dedication demonstrated by the two attorneys throughout the course of their representation.
 
 
Before the 2020 Mid-Autumn Festival, Ms. Liu arrived at her apartment in a certain district. As she opened the door, a sudden surge of standing water caught her off guard. Since the unit is a duplex, the water flowed down from the second-floor staircase, leaving both the first and second floors awash. Without time to think twice, Ms. Liu plunged into an urgent repair effort. After a frantic cleanup, they discovered that the source of the leak was the ceiling of the second-floor walk-in closet, which corresponded to the kitchen of the unit above. Following discussions with the upstairs neighbor, the other party attributed the problem to a blockage in the main sewer line and initiated a coordinated inspection of the entire building’s plumbing system. Believing the matter had been resolved, Ms. Liu returned to the apartment to sort through her belongings, which had been damaged by the floodwaters. Little did she know—her troubles were only just beginning.
 
From October 2020 to December 2020, there were 10 recorded instances of water leakage. Despite repeated negotiations with the upstairs tenant, they refused to acknowledge that their unit was responsible for the leaks. Left with no other option, Ms. Liu sought assistance from the water company, the property management, the neighborhood committee, and the police, but none of these efforts yielded any results. Each time a leak occurred, she had to rely on water‑company staff to shut off the main valve upstairs; since most leaks happened in the middle of the night, the frequent interruptions eventually became too much for the staff to bear.
 
Out of desperation, Ms. Liu brought her case to court; however, due to her lack of understanding of the litigation process and insufficient awareness of evidence‑gathering, she faced significant difficulties in presenting proof. Consequently, Ms. Liu sought assistance from Attorney Liu Cui at Chenggong Law Firm.
 
After Attorney Liu Cui became involved, he reviewed the existing evidence, excluded any items irrelevant to the case, and first obtained an expert appraisal to determine the cause of the leak, thereby refuting the third-floor resident’s defense that the leakage was due to a blockage in the main pipe. He then commissioned an assessment to quantify the extent of the damages. Following a lottery‑based selection process, a certain public appraisal firm was appointed to conduct the valuation; however, its report estimated Ms. Liu’s losses at just over RMB 10,000, a figure grossly inconsistent with the actual damage. Ms. Liu’s residence is a duplex with a substantial floor area, having been renovated in 2019 and occupied for little more than a year at the time of the incident. Due to the prolonged duration of the water exposure, the large affected area, and the high cost of remediation, coupled with the fact that no one was home when the leak occurred—resulting in extensive damage to numerous valuable garments, luggage, appliances, and other household items—the total losses were considerable. In response to the appraisal firm’s opinion, the attorney requested that the appraiser appear in court to undergo cross‑examination and, prior to trial, conducted an on‑site inspection at Ms. Liu’s home, presenting the damages in a visual, tabular format. Additionally, the attorney verified and confirmed the appraiser’s qualifications.
 
During the trial, the expert witness failed to provide a coherent response to Attorney Liu Cui’s cross-examination, leading the court to cast doubt on the appraisal. Subsequently, in further proceedings and in a supplementary explanation submitted by the appraisal institution, relying on normative documents issued by the China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission, the China Price Association, and the Shandong Provincial Price Association, as well as corroborating evidence such as the appraiser’s identity details in the appraisal report, academic credential verification from CHSI, and social security records from Dongying City, it was demonstrated that the appraiser lacked the requisite qualifications as a professional price‑appraisal expert, that the appraisal procedure was unlawful, and that the appraisal opinion lacked sufficient factual basis. In addition, more than 200 photographs and videos—systematically compiled from the time of the incident to the present—were submitted, highlighting that the appraisal report had omitted numerous losses without conducting an assessment.
 
Ultimately, the court agreed to a re‑evaluation of the damages. The new appraisal report was objective and impartial, and the first‑instance judgment upheld Ms. Liu’s claim for nearly RMB 100,000 in losses. The upstairs tenant has now repaired the source of the leak, and Ms. Liu’s life has finally returned to normal.
 
This case was successfully concluded thanks not only to the lawyer’s tireless efforts, but also to the client’s active cooperation and trust in the legal team. Upon learning that video and photographic evidence would be required, Ms. Liu meticulously captured over 300 videos and photographs, documenting both the post‑incident process of asserting her rights and the extent of the damage inside the property. At the lawyer’s guidance, she also submitted crucial evidence, including screenshots from her WeChat Moments, details from the property ownership certificate, and the rental agreement.
 
When a water leak occurs, preventing the damage from escalating is just as important as preserving first-hand evidence. The injured party should first secure the scene and document the evidence; if possible, obtain notarization of the site, and if not, take videos or photographs. Early involvement by an attorney can help ensure the case proceeds smoothly. For video and photo documentation, multiple close-up and wide-angle shots, as well as continuous video footage, are essential—capturing not only the facts of the infringement and the existence of the damage but also the precise location of the loss. Of course, after such an incident, the most effective approach is for neighbors to show mutual understanding and resolve the issue amicably.

Latest News

Post a comment