Legal Determination of the “Equal Conditions” for Shareholders’ Preemptive Subscription Rights


Legal Determination of the “Equal Conditions” for Shareholders’ Preemptive Subscription Rights

— Taking the case of Jie’an Company v. Qianfeng Company et al. concerning a dispute over the subscription of newly issued capital as an example

Senior Partner and Director of the Management Committee, Shandong Chenggong Law Firm   Zhao Qingshu

 

Abstract: Article 34 of the Company Law of the People’s Republic of China stipulates that, when a company raises additional capital, shareholders have the preemptive right to subscribe in proportion to their paid‑in capital contributions, unless all shareholders have agreed otherwise. In the case selected for this article, the parties involved have diverged in their interpretation of this provision: one party, seeking to attract a strategic investor, contends that shareholders’ preemptive subscription rights are limited to the extent of their paid‑in capital contributions, and that they lack such rights with respect to the portion waived by other shareholders and transferred to the strategic investor; the other party, by contrast, argues that, given the personal nature of a limited liability company, shareholders retain a preemptive right to subscribe for that transferred share. The author aligns with the latter view but further maintains that the exercise of such preemptive rights must be subject to equivalent conditions. As ordinary investors, can the latter group meet subscription conditions comparable to those of the strategic investor? This question hinges upon… How “equal conditions” are to be determined is precisely the central issue in this case. After analyzing and substantiating the various relevant factors, it has been concluded that the determination of “equal conditions” requires a comprehensive consideration of multiple elements.

Keywords: Preemptive subscription right    Equal conditions    Personal nature

 

I. Case Introduction

(1) Case Summary

Case source: Supreme People’s Court ( Civil Judgment No. 3 of the Second Instance, Case No. 2009

Registered capital of Qianfeng Company RMB 55 million; the company has four shareholders—Dalin Company, Yikang Company, Yigong Shengda Company, and the appellant in this case, Jie’an Company—holding 54%, 19%, 18%, and 9% of the shares, respectively. On May 28, 2007, Qianfeng Company convened an extraordinary shareholders’ meeting, with the agenda item being: to ensure the company’s restructuring and listing, all shareholders would reduce their equity holdings in proportion to their shareholdings, raising RMB 20 million by issuing 20 million shares at RMB 2.8 per share, and introducing strategic investors. Following a vote, the meeting adopted the following resolution: : First, Dalin Company, Yikang Company, and Yigong Shengda Company have agreed to waive their rights to subscribe for the newly issued capital, which will instead be subscribed by strategic investors. These investors are required to commit to a specific timeline for the company’s IPO and a predetermined share offering price, and to affirm that this arrangement is undertaken solely for the purposes of the company’s restructuring and listing, without seeking any personal gain. In favor. 91%, opposed by 9% (Jian’an Company); Second, Agree that Jie’an Company shall subscribe for the capital contribution at a premium, in proportion to its shareholding. 9% of the new capital, with 100% in favor; Third, The subscriber must at Funds must be remitted to the company’s account by May 31, 2007; otherwise, such contribution shall be deemed waived, with 100% approval. On May 29, all shareholder representatives signed the resolution. At the same time, Jie’an Company stated its opposition to the subscription of the newly issued capital by strategic investors and submitted a memorandum of its views to the shareholders’ meeting of Qianfeng Company, requesting that it exercise its preemptive right to subscribe for the shares renounced by other shareholders; however, this request was not approved. Jie’an Company contends that Qianfeng Company and the other shareholders have infringed upon its preemptive subscription rights and has therefore brought suit before the court, seeking a judgment confirming that Jie’an Company is entitled to the preemptive right to subscribe for the portion of the newly issued capital renounced by the other shareholders.

The appellant contends that, in light of the personal‑relationship nature of a limited liability company, shareholders are entitled to preemptive rights to subscribe for shares that other shareholders have waived their subscription obligations to. The appellee, by contrast, argues that Qianfeng Company’s capital increase was undertaken for specific purposes and under particular conditions, not to raise additional funds for development, and therefore the appellant has no right to exercise preemptive subscription rights with respect to that portion of the capital.

The Guizhou Provincial High People’s Court, in its first-instance ruling, held that shareholders do not have a preemptive right to subscribe for the shares that other shareholders have waived, and accordingly dismissed Jie’an Company’s claim. Jie’an Company appealed, dissatisfied with the decision. In its second-instance review, the Supreme People’s Court found the shareholders’ resolution valid and binding on all shareholders, and affirmed the original judgment.

(II) The Focus of the Dispute — Determination of “Equal Conditions”

The shareholders’ preemptive subscription right refers to the right, after a limited liability company is established, to increase its registered capital in accordance with statutory conditions and procedures in order to expand production. Based on the personal nature of a limited liability company, existing shareholders enjoy the right, at a predetermined price and in proportion to their capital contributions, to subscribe for the newly added registered capital prior to any third parties. Furthermore, also grounded in the personal nature of such companies, shareholders possess the preemptive right of first refusal. When equity interests are transferred to an external party, dissenting shareholders may… The preemptive right to subscribe shall be exercised under “equal conditions.” By the same legal principle, shareholders should also exercise their preemptive right to subscribe for any newly issued capital shares that other shareholders have waived their subscription rights to and transferred to external investors, again on “equal conditions.”

Based on the facts of the case and the foregoing analysis, it is clear that the appellant contends that the price and timing for exercising its preemptive subscription right, as determined by the capital‑increase resolution, are consistent with those applicable to a strategic investor who is not a shareholder; thus, the conditions for exercising such preemptive rights are satisfied. “Equal conditions”—the appellee contends that the appellant cannot commit to the company’s timing of its IPO or the offering price, and therefore fails to meet the “equal conditions” applicable to strategic investors. Accordingly, when determining whether “equal conditions” are satisfied, should consideration be given not only to factors such as the subscription price, the number of shares subscribed, and the payment schedule, but also to other balancing considerations?

II. Standards for Determining “Equal Conditions”

(1) “Transfer Price” Factor

Related to the academic community There are three mainstream doctrines regarding the criteria for determining “equal conditions”: the absolute equality doctrine, the relative equality doctrine, and the compromise doctrine. The absolute equality doctrine—sometimes referred to by some scholars as the “contract‑replication doctrine”—holds that a shareholder exercising pre‑emptive subscription rights must offer subscription terms that are identical to those agreed upon between the transferring shareholder and external investors in order to satisfy the “equal conditions.” By contrast, the relative equality doctrine maintains that it suffices for the subscribing terms offered by the preemptive shareholder to be broadly consistent with those proposed to external investors, provided that, in substance, they are no less favorable than the terms advanced by the external investors, thereby establishing “equal conditions.” Advocates of the compromise doctrine contend that, to meet the “equal conditions,” the exercising shareholder need only ensure that the transfer price, the method of contribution, and the payment schedule—factors that materially affect the transferring shareholder’s interests under the new‑share transfer agreement—are identical to those stipulated in the contract.

Taking into account the various doctrinal perspectives, both the absolute equivalence theory and the compromise theory affirm that the consistency of the transfer price is decisive for determining… The role of “equal conditions” also, from another perspective, underscores the importance of price. “Equal conditions” are often equated with identical pricing, and this view has its merits. On the one hand, shareholders transfer their equity interests or their entitlement to newly issued capital shares primarily to secure investment funds; accordingly, price becomes the factor of paramount concern for both the company and the shareholders. On the other hand, price serves as the most concrete criterion among all factors considered in determining “equal conditions”; it is objective, straightforward to compare, and less likely to give rise to unnecessary disputes.

(2) “Subscribed amount” factor

With regard to whether shareholders may exercise their preemptive rights in part, the academic community is divided into two schools of thought: the affirmative view and the negative view. The affirmative view holds that shareholders may exercise their preemptive rights partially, for the following reasons: ( 1 ) The Company Law does not preclude shareholders from exercising their preemptive rights in part. ( 2 ) The legislative purpose of the right of first refusal is to safeguard the interests of existing shareholders and protect their priority in acquiring control of the company. If a shareholder can obtain control by exercising the right of first refusal with respect to a portion of the equity, there would be no need to exercise that right over the entire transferred shareholding. ( 3 ) Equity in a limited liability company is, by its very nature, divisible. The Company Law grants shareholders the right to transfer only a portion of their shares; accordingly, the transferee likewise has the right to acquire a partial interest, and the other shareholders, in turn, enjoy a preemptive right to purchase the transferred portion. Scholars who advocate a negative view contend that: ( 4 ) One of the legislative objectives of the right of first refusal is to preserve the personal nature of a limited liability company. Allowing shareholders to exercise this right only in part merely safeguards the existing shareholders’ control over the company, without preventing third parties from entering the company, and thus fails to achieve the legislative goal of maintaining the company’s personal character. ( 5 ) In certain cases of external equity transfers, the non‑shareholder seeks to acquire control of the company, and the number of shares acquired is decisive in determining whether such control will be obtained.

The author agrees with the negative view, as the legislative approach to the partial exercise of preemptive subscription rights is inconsistent with that governing shareholders’ preemptive subscription rights. As illustrated in the case selected for this article, in Qianfeng Company, three shareholders—including Daling Company—undertook to waive their preemptive subscription rights in proportion to their respective shareholdings, thereby relinquishing their entitlement to subscribe for the newly issued capital shares. 18.2 million shares, valued at a total of RMB 509.6 million, were transferred to strategic investors, while Qianfeng Company’s registered capital stood at only RMB 55 million. The rationale for transferring this newly issued capital—which is pivotal to the company’s control—is to enable the strategic investor to gain controlling interest in Qianfeng and thereby facilitate the company’s restructuring and subsequent public listing. If shareholders were permitted to exercise their preemptive subscription rights partially, then once Jie’an Company exercised even a portion of its preemptive rights, it could undermine the control‑related value embedded in the shareholdings being transferred by other shareholders, potentially prompting the strategic investor to withdraw from the investment. Accordingly, partial exercise of preemptive subscription rights by shareholders is, in principle, prohibited.

(3) “Obligation of Performance” factor

An ancillary obligation is a contractual duty that is subordinate to the principal obligation and, while not independently determinative of the contract’s nature, serves to ensure that the parties’ contractual interests are realized to the greatest possible extent. Given that, in certain contracts for the transfer of additional capital shares, ancillary obligation clauses play a crucial role in maximizing the rights and interests of the company and its shareholders, where the factors underlying the principal obligation are found to be satisfied on an equal footing, judicial determination… In cases of “equal conditions,” it is also necessary to assess whether the exercising shareholder satisfies the “obligation of ancillary performance” stipulated in the transfer agreement. In the cases examined in this article, with the exception of Jie’an Company, the other shareholders required the strategic investor to make commitments regarding the company’s timetable for going public and the price at which its shares would be issued. However, Jie’an Company did not undertake to fulfill such an ancillary obligation toward Qianfeng Company or the other shareholders; accordingly, it should be determined that it does not meet the “ancillary obligation” criterion under the standard of equal conditions.

III. Conclusion

As interpreted in the Property Law —— On the Determination of the Right of First Refusal to Purchase a Co-ownership Share “Equal terms” item As stipulated, when determining whether a shareholder’s preemptive subscription right is exercised under “equal conditions,” factors such as the transfer price, the amount of capital to be subscribed, the contribution deadline, ancillary obligations, and liability for breach of contract must also be taken into account.

In this case, the appellee, for the purpose of restructuring and listing the company, required the strategic investor to commit to a specific listing timetable and an issuance price. The condition of the ancillary obligation under the contract, which the appellant, as an ordinary investor, cannot satisfy. , Subsequently, an appeal was filed. A person cannot satisfy the exercise of the preemptive subscription right. “Equal conditions.”

References

1. Song Xiaoming and Liu Junhai, eds., Comprehensive Compilation of Key Points from Guiding Cases on Corporate Law Issued by the People’s Courts, Beijing: Peking University Press, 2014.

2. Wang Jun: “Company Law of China,” Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2015 edition.

3. Zhao Xudong, ed., Corporate Law, Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2006 edition.

4. Dieter Medicus, “Specific Provisions of German Law of Obligations,” translated by Du Jinglin and Lu Chen, Beijing: Law Press, 2007 edition.

 

Commentary: The vitality of legal norms lies in judicial practice. Legal norms often require interpretation to be applicable in judicial proceedings. Article 34 of the Company Law of the People’s Republic of China stipulates that… Divergent interpretations of “equal conditions” can lead to disparate judicial outcomes in individual cases. This article demonstrates a keen awareness of the issues at hand; by drawing on Supreme Court precedents, it identifies and analyzes key problems before advancing its own position. Its reasoning is clear, and its conclusions are highly persuasive.

 

 

Latest News

Post a comment