The case represented by Attorney Zhao Qingshu of our firm was selected as a “Typical Case of Administrative Adjudication in Qingdao, 2019.”
Release date:
2020-03-23 14:28
Source:
On March 5, the Qingdao Intermediate People’s Court held a press conference via video link, releasing the 2019 Judicial Review Report on Administrative Cases (Administrative Trial White Paper) for the city’s courts, along with ten landmark cases. Numerous media outlets participated remotely. The case “Shandong Certain Yellow Wine Factory Co., Ltd. v. People’s Government of Jimo District, Qingdao; and Jimo District Bureau of Culture, Radio, Television, Press and Publication of Qingdao—Registration and Public Announcement of Cultural Relics,” represented by Attorney Zhao Qingshu, Senior Partner, Deputy Director, and Director of the Management Committee at Chenggong Law Firm, was selected as one of the 2019 Qingdao Administrative Trial Typical Cases. (Click the link to view Case No. 5: 2019 Qingdao Administrative Trial Typical Cases.)
Following his appointment by the defendant, the Qingdao Jimo District Bureau of Culture, Radio, Television, Press and Publication, Attorney Zhao Qingshu of this firm promptly conducted a thorough and comprehensive review of the case file, meticulously organized the factual information, and overcame numerous challenges inherent in the representation. Ultimately, the Intermediate People’s Court of Qingdao rendered a judgment rejecting the plaintiff’s claims, with the court declining to accept the plaintiff’s arguments. This case was subsequently selected as a notable example. In 2019, Qingdao’s administrative adjudication system highlighted several landmark cases that, through their rulings, guided plaintiff enterprises to appropriately leverage the cultural value inherent in immovable cultural relics in their future development and construction projects. At the same time, these cases encouraged relevant cultural heritage authorities and government departments to adopt innovative approaches, integrate the protection of immovable cultural relics with coordinated economic development, and promote local businesses in using such relics as a platform for fostering the cultural industries. This not only advanced the cause of cultural heritage preservation but also helped prevent conflicts with local economic interests, thereby fully demonstrating the professional competence and expertise of our firm’s attorneys.
It is reported that the Intermediate People’s Court has released ten typical cases, covering areas of public concern such as workplace safety, food and drug regulation, and land‑expropriation compensation, as well as economic and cultural matters including tax penalties, registration of shareholder changes, and the public announcement of cultural relics. By elucidating the law through these landmark cases, the court provides guidance to the public for safeguarding their rights in a lawful and rational manner, and to administrative agencies for conducting administration in accordance with the law.
Case Details
[Summary of the Judgment]
Cultural relics registered as immovable cultural relics are subject to the constraints and protection of the Law of the People’s Republic of China on the Protection of Cultural Relics and other relevant laws and regulations. In light of this, the competent authorities for cultural relics should strictly regulate the procedures for the verification, registration, and public announcement of cultural relics, thereby safeguarding the legitimate rights and interests of owners and users during the registration process. At the same time, while enjoying the economic and cultural benefits arising from such registration, owners and users should also assume the obligation to ensure lawful, reasonable, and appropriate utilization of these cultural relics.
[Basic Facts of the Case]
The former site of the yellow‑wine factory involved in this case was built in 1980 and is owned by the plaintiff. On October 22, 2007, the defendant, the Jimo District Government, in accordance with the requirements of the State Council and the People’s Government of Shandong Province for conducting the Third National Cultural Relics Census, decided to carry out a citywide census. Following procedures including the establishment of a census office, staff training, collection of relevant materials, on-site surveys, and tiered expert reviews, on May 9, 2012, the Jimo District Bureau of Culture, Radio, Television, Press and Publication issued the “Notice on the Publication of the List of Newly Discovered Immovable Cultural Relics from the Third National Cultural Relics Census in the District,” designating the former site of the yellow‑wine factory as an “Important Historical Site and Representative Building of the Recent and Modern Period.” On February 16, 2016, the defendant district government issued the “Notice on the Publication of the ‘List of Immovable Cultural Relics from the Third National Cultural Relics Census in the District,’” which was posted on the government’s official website, listing the former site of the yellow‑wine factory as an immovable cultural relic.
On April 27, 2017, the plaintiff entered into an Asset Transfer Agreement with the third party, a certain investment management company in Qingdao, pursuant to which the disputed yellow wine factory was transferred to the third party. On November 10, 2017, upon learning of this arrangement, the defendant, the Jimo District Bureau of Culture, Radio, Television and Tourism, issued a letter to the plaintiff titled “Notice on Strengthening the Protection of the Former Site of the Disputed Yellow Wine Factory,” instructing the plaintiff to proceed in accordance with statutory procedures and to ensure the safety of the immovable cultural relic. On January 30, 2018, the plaintiff submitted a written objection to the defendant, the Jimo District Bureau of Culture, Radio, Television and Tourism, asserting that it had been unaware of the government’s notice and contending that the former site of the yellow wine factory did not qualify as a protected cultural relic. On February 22, 2018, the defendant, the Jimo District Bureau of Culture, Radio, Television and Tourism, responded to the plaintiff, stating that the procedure by which the former site of the yellow wine factory was designated as an immovable cultural relic was lawful and valid, and that the site is indeed classified as a protected cultural relic. Dissatisfied with this decision, the plaintiff brought the matter before the court.
[Judgment Result]
The court’s final judgment holds that, in accordance with the requirements of the Third National Cultural Relics Census, the defendant, the Jimo District Government, established a census leading group and an office. In 2008, staff members of the census office designated the former site of the yellow‑wine factory at issue as a newly discovered immovable cultural relic in the course of the Third National Cultural Relics Census, registered it accordingly, and, in 2010, obtained approval following expert review by the offices of the Qingdao Municipal and Shandong Provincial Leading Groups for the Third National Cultural Relics Census. The “Preliminary Inspection Report on the Field Survey Phase of the Third National Cultural Relics Census in the City Involved” and the “Acceptance Conclusion on the Field Survey Phase of the Third National Cultural Relics Census in the City Involved,” both submitted by the defendant, the Jimo District Bureau of Culture, Radio, Television and Tourism, constitute professional assessments rendered by qualified experts. The plaintiff contends that the designation of the former yellow‑wine factory site as an immovable cultural relic constitutes an error of fact; however, the plaintiff has neither presented evidence to substantiate this claim nor offered any contrary evidence to challenge the validity of the aforementioned acceptance conclusions. Accordingly, the court rejects this assertion. The Law of the People’s Republic of China on the Protection of Cultural Relics, together with relevant laws and regulations, does not expressly prescribe specific procedures or formalities for the registration and public announcement of immovable cultural relics. In the present case, the former yellow‑wine factory site was duly registered as an immovable cultural relic after undergoing a series of steps, including the establishment of a census office, organization of personnel training, collection of pertinent materials, on‑site investigation, and successive expert reviews—thus complying with the principle of due process. Furthermore, the defendants published the contents of their notice on their official website, making it readily accessible to the general public at any time; therefore, they have fulfilled their obligation to make such information publicly available. Upon learning that the yellow‑wine factory in question was being transferred, the defendant, the Jimo District Bureau of Culture, Radio, Television and Tourism, notified the plaintiff to proceed in accordance with statutory procedures and ensured the safety of the immovable cultural relic—an action that demonstrates proactive performance of its duties in cultural relic management and protection, consistent with the legislative intent and spirit of the Law of the People’s Republic of China on the Protection of Cultural Relics. Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiff’s claims.
[Typical Significance]
Over the past three decades, dramatic shifts in social lifestyles and values, coupled with the accelerating pace of urbanization, have placed China’s immovable cultural heritage under severe strain. The exemplary significance of this case lies in its role in overseeing the competent cultural heritage authorities to ensure that the procedures for identifying and registering cultural relics are strictly standardized, while also guiding owners and users of immovable cultural relics that have already been officially registered and designated to cultivate an awareness of lawful, reasonable, and appropriate utilization.
Generally speaking, immovable cultural relics that have not been designated as protected sites are registered and publicly announced by the cultural heritage administrative department of the people’s government at the county level, with records kept and protective measures specified and implemented. What is particularly noteworthy in this case is that the former site of the yellow‑wine factory involved was registered and announced as an immovable cultural relic during the Third National Cultural Relics Census. According to the plan for the Third Census, the competent cultural heritage administrative authority at the county level, together with the corresponding local administrative authority—namely, the Jimo District Bureau of Culture, Radio, Television, and Tourism and the Jimo District People’s Government—designates and publicly announces such immovable cultural relics. Since Articles 24, 25, and 26 of the Law of the People’s Republic of China on the Protection of Cultural Relics impose certain legal obligations on the owners and users of registered immovable cultural relics, and these obligations substantially affect their rights and interests, the administrative organs vested with the power to register and announce immovable cultural relics must strictly adhere to relevant laws and regulations, clearly define the criteria for identification, and, through the collection of pertinent materials and on‑site investigations, fully safeguard the right of owners and users to be informed and to participate, thereby enabling them to actively engage in the registration and public announcement process. On the other hand, as owners of cultural relics, while enjoying the cultural benefits conferred by their designation as immovable cultural relics, they are also required by law to fulfill their obligation to protect those relics.
The court exercised the proactive role of the judiciary, recognizing the Jimo District Bureau of Culture, Radio, Television, and Tourism’s diligent fulfillment of its duties: upon learning that the former site of the yellow‑wine factory in question was slated for transfer, the bureau proactively issued a letter advising the plaintiff to follow the legally prescribed procedures and ensuring the safety of the immovable cultural relic. Moreover, through its judgment, the court guided the plaintiff enterprise to make prudent use of the cultural value inherent in the immovable cultural relic in its future development and construction projects. This litigation has also prompted the local cultural heritage authorities and government agencies to adopt a more forward‑looking approach, integrating the protection of immovable cultural relics with balanced economic development, and encouraging local enterprises to leverage these relics as platforms for cultivating the cultural‑industry economy—thereby advancing the cause of cultural preservation while preventing conflicts with local economic interests.
Latest News
Post a comment