On the Offensive Strategies in Corporate Patent Litigation


  On the Offensive Strategies in Corporate Patent Litigation
 
  Corporate patent litigation strategy is a crucial tactical component of implementing an enterprise’s overall patent strategy. This approach transplants the offensive–defensive mindset from the battlefield into the commercial arena: when the plaintiff initiates a patent lawsuit, it launches an attack against the opponent; for the defendant, mounting a defense to safeguard its own interests constitutes the defensive response. An offensive patent litigation strategy refers to the proactive legal action taken by a patent holder or an interested party—motivated by market‑competition imperatives—to sue another entity for patent infringement. By wielding patent rights as an offensive tool, such a strategy seeks to undermine or deter competitors and secure market advantages, including increased market share and economic gains. In competitive markets, offensive patent litigation typically arises when a company, acting as the plaintiff, files an infringement suit against a rival, thereby triggering a patent‑infringement dispute. This represents the use of patents’ inherent deterrent power to launch an attack on a competitor. However, patent litigation possesses distinct characteristics and patterns, particularly given its intersection with technical, legal, and economic issues, which often render cases highly complex. Consequently, when initiating a patent‑infringement action, companies must anticipate a range of potential challenges and design their litigation strategies in alignment with the unique features and underlying dynamics of patent disputes.
 
  I. Thorough Preparation Prior to Filing a Lawsuit
  To achieve the objectives of patent litigation, companies must undertake thorough preparation before launching a patent‑related legal challenge against their competitors. As Sun Tzu’s Art of War puts it, “He who wins the battle before it is fought has calculated his chances and found them favorable; he who loses the battle before it is fought has calculated his chances and found them unfavorable.” This underscores the need for meticulous planning and analysis prior to engaging in conflict, ensuring that adequate preparation leads to a higher likelihood of success. The same principle applies equally to the preparatory work enterprises undertake before initiating patent litigation.
  Preparatory work prior to patent litigation primarily encompasses the following two aspects:
  1. Collect evidence.
  Evidence is the lifeblood and linchpin of litigation, serving as the bridge that connects substantive law with procedural law. Whether the information submitted by the parties to the people’s court during the proceedings is admissible and can be relied upon as the basis for establishing the facts of the case directly affects the realization and protection of the parties’ substantive rights. Accordingly, enterprises must, in light of the specific needs of patent litigation, diligently gather and preserve evidentiary materials to effectively prove the occurrence of infringement and substantiate their claims.
  In accordance with the requirements of patent infringement litigation, the evidence that a company must gather for filing a lawsuit is typically collected from the following three aspects:
  (1) Evidence proving one’s rights.
  The primary evidence of one’s rights is the patent certificate, which directly establishes both the patent right and the identity of the rights holder. Next comes the patent register, which records the ongoing status and any changes to the patent right. In addition, payment receipts and patent evaluation reports may also serve as evidence of rights; the latter can further demonstrate that the patent meets the conditions for grant. All these documents can be obtained directly by the patent owner upon presentation of appropriate identification. The patent register and the patent evaluation report may be applied for and issued by the patent owner through the National Intellectual Property Administration.
  (2) Evidence proving the existence of the infringing act.
  The direct evidence proving the fact of infringement is typically the infringing product itself, whether it is manufactured or sold. Other forms of evidence include sales invoices, contracts, and promotional advertisements. The allegedly infringing product constitutes the most crucial evidence; one may purchase it from the point of sale and use the purchased item together with the accompanying invoice as proof. However, if the party obtains such evidence independently, it often proves difficult to admit as admissible evidence in court due to the opposing party’s challenges regarding its authenticity. In light of this, when seeking to gather evidence of infringement, the plaintiff should have the evidence preserved by a competent authority. There are two primary methods of preservation: first, notarized preservation—where, upon purchasing the allegedly infringing product, the plaintiff requests the notary office to certify the entire transaction; the notarized product and purchase documentation are then highly reliable and hard to dispute. Second, filing an application for judicial evidence preservation: concurrently with the filing of the lawsuit, the plaintiff submits a request to the court to preserve evidence at a designated location. Evidence collected by the judge at the manufacturing or sales site of the allegedly infringing product can likewise serve as effective proof of the existence of the infringing act.
  (3) Evidence proving one’s losses.
  Proving loss—i.e., establishing the factual damage caused by the infringing act—has long been a major challenge in patent infringement litigation. As a constituent element of intellectual property infringement, the fact of loss must be objective and genuine. In accordance with the Patent Law of the People’s Republic of China, losses resulting from patent infringement may be proven as follows: first, demonstrate the actual losses suffered by the rights holder due to the infringement; if such actual losses are difficult to prove, evidence may be adduced to establish the profits obtained by the infringer, which can then be deemed the rights holder’s loss. If both the rights holder’s loss and the infringer’s gains remain uncertain—for instance, where the patent is subject to licensing—the parties may submit the licensing agreement, and the court may reasonably determine the amount of damages by applying a multiple of the license fee. Where the rights holder’s loss, the infringer’s gains, and the patent licensing fee are all difficult to ascertain, a party may petition the court to make an equitable determination of damages. The people’s court may, taking into account factors such as the type of patent right, the nature of the infringing act, and the specific circumstances, award compensation ranging from RMB 10,000 to RMB 1 million.
  When determining the amount of damages, it is essential to base it on the actual circumstances and avoid setting it excessively high; otherwise, the court may refuse to award such damages, and you will also be required to bear the litigation costs yourself. If it is difficult to provide evidence of the losses, you may directly request the court to make an equitable determination of the damages. To enhance the court’s assessment of the damage amount, you can submit materials demonstrating the patent’s value, such as certificates of awards, expert appraisal reports, and information on the defendant’s scale of production and operations. Such evidence can help the court better appreciate the patent’s value and facilitate a more accurate determination of damages.
  2. Conducting an analytical argument for the lawsuit
  After the enterprise has obtained the necessary certifications, the next step is to conduct an analytical and argumentative review of the litigation.
  First, the evidence obtained should be organized in a logical sequence—namely, evidence of rights, evidence of infringement, and evidence of damages—and its content should be analyzed to determine whether it adequately establishes the facts of infringement and the extent of the resulting losses, in light of the litigation’s objectives.
  Secondly, it is necessary to assess the stability of the patent right on which the lawsuit is based—specifically, by conducting a prior-art search or reviewing relevant prior art to determine whether the patent meets the statutory requirements for grant. If the patent’s validity is questionable in light of the prior art, filing a patent‑infringement action should be approached with great caution, so as to avoid losing the case should the opposing party initiate an invalidation proceeding during the litigation.
  Subsequently, patent‑infringement analysis and argumentation are conducted. Conducting such an analysis is a critically important pre‑litigation step. It provides a comprehensive assessment of the competitive landscape prior to launching a patent‑related offensive, serves as a predictive evaluation of the likely outcome should litigation be initiated, and ultimately determines whether the company should pursue adversarial litigation. At the same time, patent‑infringement analysis is a highly specialized task; if the company or its counsel finds it difficult to undertake this work independently, they may engage a professional expert institution to perform an infringement determination.
  Based on the foregoing analysis and argumentation, if the likelihood of success is deemed substantial, litigation may be initiated; conversely, if the prospects of success are slim, it is advisable to forgo litigation. However, if the enterprise seeks to deter a competitor, pursue cooperation with a competitor, or capitalize on the opportunity for publicity, it may not need to require a high probability of success in bringing suit.
 
  II. Selection of the Defendant in a Lawsuit
  The defendant in a patent‑infringement lawsuit is the infringer, and in a competitive market, such infringers are often a company’s rivals. When there is only a single infringer, there is no question of choosing among defendants. However, when a patent‑infringement action involves multiple alleged infringers, it becomes a matter of strategic importance for the plaintiff to decide whether to name one, several, or all of them as defendants. If the plaintiff opts to sue several or all of the infringers, it first faces the challenge of serving process, which may prolong the litigation due to difficulties in delivery. Moreover, if among the multiple defendants there is a particularly formidable opponent—either financially robust or experienced in intellectual‑property litigation—the plaintiff may encounter a vigorous counterattack, leaving its case on the defensive and potentially jeopardizing the likelihood of success.
  In response to the aforementioned issues, if a patent holder plans to file lawsuits against multiple infringers, it is advisable to begin with the weakest defendant. This approach helps establish a legally binding precedent, thereby reducing the risk of pursuing stronger infringers in subsequent cases. Put simply, when selecting whom to sue, start with the easier targets—attacking the competitor’s weaker points—and build on incremental victories to achieve broader success, ultimately advancing the company’s market strategy. However, if the company’s objective is to deter competitors or serve promotional purposes, it may directly target more formidable rivals or large corporations, thus better achieving its litigation goals.
 
  III. Determination of the Litigation Objectives
  After evidence has been gathered and the parties to be sued have been identified, the enterprise should establish the objectives of this patent litigation in light of the relevant factual circumstances. Depending on the company’s competitive needs, patent litigation typically pursues the following types of objectives:
  1. Drive competitors out of the competitive market.
  This strategy is suited to enterprises with sufficient financial resources to cover substantial litigation costs, where the fact of patent infringement by a competitor is clear and supported by solid evidence. Under such circumstances, the company can proactively initiate an offensive lawsuit. Following judicial proceedings, if the court finds that the competitor has indeed infringed, it will order the cessation of the infringing conduct. As a result, the competitor is forced out of the market for the patented product, enabling the company to pursue its business strategy of capturing market share through patent litigation.
  2. Achieving Economic Benefits
  When a competitor is found to have infringed the company’s patent rights, and basic evidence of infringement has been established, yet the company lacks any intention to monopolize the market, it can initiate patent‑infringement litigation to compel the competitor to engage in good‑faith negotiations. Such negotiations may result in either the payment of monetary damages or the conclusion of a patent‑licensing agreement, under which the licensee makes periodic royalty payments, thereby generating additional economic benefits for the company. For example, Japan’s 6C Consortium accused Chinese companies of infringing its DVD patents and pressured them to pay licensing fees, all in pursuit of financial gain. It should be noted that entities or organizations that acquire ownership or usage rights to patents—through research, acquisition, or other means—but neither manufacture patented products nor provide patented services, instead filing patent‑infringement lawsuits against firms using their patents without authorization in order to extract license fees, damages, or settlement payments, are commonly referred to in the industry as “patent trolls.” These actors often face widespread public criticism and mounting calls for legislative restrictions. This paper examines litigation strategies employed in the context of inter‑firm market competition, with the primary subjects being manufacturing and operating enterprises; “patent trolls” are excluded from this scope.
  3. Restrict the development of competitors
  This objective applies to companies that do not seek a definitive victory or defeat in patent litigation, instead using litigation as a tool to ultimately achieve the commercial goal of curbing their competitors’ growth. For the plaintiff, filing an infringement suit against a rival often prompts its partners to exercise caution, leading them to slow down or suspend transactions—thereby forfeiting numerous business opportunities and stifling the competitor’s momentum. For the defendant, mounting counter‑suits against a rival enables it to deploy various measures to blunt the adversary’s offensive, safeguard its own production and operational achievements, and, to some extent, restrain the competitor’s expansion.
  4. Seeking Cooperation
  This objective is primarily applicable when companies of comparable strength have mutual technological or other needs and cannot achieve the goal of undermining a competitor through patent litigation. In such cases, cooperation can be fostered via reciprocal arrangements like cross‑licensing, thereby pursuing mutual benefit and win‑win outcomes. Additionally, this objective also applies when a weaker firm seeks to collaborate with a stronger one by resorting to patent‑infringement litigation.
  Enterprises should select litigation strategy objectives that align with their intellectual property strategy and the specific objective conditions they face. For instance, companies that are financially robust and technologically advanced may aim to drive competitors out of the market or secure economic gains through litigation. When the parties’ strengths are roughly equal or when they have mutual commercial interests, the goal may instead be to pursue cooperation or to curb the competitor’s growth.
 
  IV. Choice of Venue for Filing the Lawsuit
  The choice of venue for filing a lawsuit—i.e., the issue of court jurisdiction—is governed by the Civil Procedure Law of the People’s Republic of China and relevant judicial interpretations on patent matters. According to these provisions, lawsuits arising from infringement are under the jurisdiction of the people’s court at the place where the infringing act occurred or at the defendant’s domicile. Consequently, when a company brings suit against a competitor on the grounds of patent infringement, it has two options: either file in the defendant’s domicile or in the place where the infringing act took place. If the defendant is located in another jurisdiction, it is generally not advisable for the plaintiff to choose the defendant’s domicile as the venue, because doing so places the defendant in a favorable position—benefiting from local advantages and the support of their home‑court environment—while leaving the plaintiff at a disadvantage, often introducing numerous uncertainties that can undermine the plaintiff’s ability to protect its rights and implement its competitive strategy.
  Accordingly, it is advisable for the plaintiff to select the place where the infringement occurred, as relevant judicial interpretations provide multiple options for such a location. These include the places where acts of manufacturing, using, offering for sale, selling, or importing products alleged to infringe an invention or utility model patent are carried out; the place where a patented method is practiced, as well as the places where products directly obtained through that method are used, offered for sale, sold, or imported; the places where acts of manufacturing, offering for sale, selling, or importing products covered by a design patent are performed; and the place where acts of counterfeiting another’s patent take place. Moreover, the place where the consequences of the aforementioned infringing acts arise may also be considered. When several venues are available, it is prudent for the rights holder to file suit in the court whose jurisdiction best serves their interests. Additionally, the court’s approach to determining damages should be taken into account: if one court tends to award higher compensation than others, prioritizing that court may enable the plaintiff to secure a more substantial monetary remedy.
  With respect to the choice of venue for infringement actions, the most critical factors are the place of manufacture and the place of sale of the allegedly infringing product. In practice, the manufacturer and the seller may be located in different jurisdictions; in such cases, it is necessary to determine whether the court at the place of sale has jurisdiction—that is, whether a lawsuit may be brought before that court—and also to address jurisdictional issues arising when the manufacturer and the seller are not the same entity. In this regard, pursuant to the relevant provisions of judicial interpretations: if the seller is a branch of the manufacturer, and the plaintiff brings suit in the place of sale against the manufacturer for the acts of manufacturing and selling the infringing product, the people’s court at the place of sale has jurisdiction. If the plaintiff sues only the manufacturer and does not name the seller, and the place of manufacture differs from the place of sale, the people’s court at the place of manufacture has jurisdiction. However, if both the manufacturer and the seller are named as joint defendants, then the people’s court at the place of sale has jurisdiction. These issues must be carefully clarified when determining the proper court with jurisdiction.
 
  V. Timing of Filing the Lawsuit
  When a company initiates litigation against a competitor, the timing of the action is critically important. A well‑timed filing increases the likelihood of achieving the litigation’s objectives and securing substantial economic benefits. Conversely, an ill‑chosen timing can lead to significant challenges during the proceedings and may even result in failure. For example, filing suit while the competitor is still in the preparatory stage—before the infringing product has been launched—can make evidence‑gathering extremely difficult and risk alerting the rival, thereby undermining the intended deterrent effect. Similarly, bringing suit when the competitor is on the brink of bankruptcy may prove futile, as the defendant no longer poses a meaningful threat and lacks the financial capacity to pay damages.
  Accordingly, when filing an infringement lawsuit against a competitor, companies should carefully time their actions to capitalize on the following opportunities:
  1. Choose to file a lawsuit after your competitor has already invested in cultivating the market. If you discover that a competitor is engaging in infringing activities, do not rush to initiate litigation at that stage. Instead, wait until the competitor has incurred substantial production and marketing costs and the market has reached a certain level of maturity, then seize the opportune moment to bring a patent‑infringement suit. The advantage of this approach is that, upon winning, you can secure substantial monetary damages while delivering a severe blow to your rival. This “let the fish grow in the water and settle the score in autumn” strategy is frequently employed by multinational corporations. For example, Japan’s 6C Consortium, which holds core patents for DVD technology, refrained from enforcing its rights when Chinese companies first began producing DVD products. Only after the market had matured in China did it launch patent‑infringement claims, thereby obtaining sizable damages and licensing fees and inflicting heavy losses on China’s DVD industry.
  2. Choose to sue competitors during their major events. In particular, competitors tend to initiate litigation when they are going public or negotiating and signing significant partnership agreements. At such times, companies are generally reluctant to confront litigation risks and lack the resources to engage in protracted, high‑cost legal battles. Moreover, they seek to avoid tarnishing their reputation among shareholders, investors, or partners due to patent‑infringement lawsuits. Under these circumstances, competitors often yield voluntarily, making concessions in an effort to reach a settlement with the plaintiff.
  3. File a lawsuit when your competitor is in distress. At such times, the competitor is often grappling with a host of management, operational, and financial challenges, leaving it with limited capacity to mount an effective defense. Consequently, initiating litigation at this juncture typically encounters little robust resistance, making it easier to achieve your legal objectives.
 
  VI. Choice of Litigation Method
  With regard to the method of filing a lawsuit, the following options are available in practice:
  1. Filing a lawsuit after issuing a formal notice: Prior to filing suit, send the other party an infringement warning letter or engage an attorney to issue a legal letter, informing them that their conduct constitutes patent infringement and proposing a resolution. If the other party ignores the notice and persists in its infringing behavior, bring a patent infringement action against them in court.
  2. Progressive Filing of Lawsuits: This approach is suitable when the opposing party has infringed multiple of the plaintiff’s patents. After filing a patent infringement suit against the defendant, if the defendant refuses to comply or mounts a vigorous counterattack, the plaintiff may file another lawsuit alleging infringement of yet another patent, and then progressively escalate the legal action until the defendant yields.
  3. A “mountain‑crushing, sea‑overwhelming” filing strategy: This approach is also applicable when the defendant has infringed multiple of the plaintiff’s patents. Rather than filing separate lawsuits for each individual patent, the plaintiff brings a single action encompassing all the patents that have been infringed, mounting such a formidable legal challenge that the defendant finds it difficult to defend itself, thereby achieving the plaintiff’s litigation objectives.
  4. Multipronged Litigation: This litigation strategy is applicable when the defendant’s infringement of the plaintiff’s patent rights occurs in multiple jurisdictions. Under such circumstances, the plaintiff may file patent‑infringement actions simultaneously in several courts across different locations, thereby placing the defendant under significant pressure to respond.
  It should be noted that adopting either a phased‑in litigation strategy or an all‑at‑once, mass‑filing approach requires the plaintiff to possess a substantial portfolio of patents; otherwise, such litigation tactics would be difficult to implement.
  At present, most Chinese enterprises still exhibit a relatively weak awareness of patents and have not fully appreciated the value of patent litigation. Many people view patent litigation merely as an initial stage of rights protection, evaluating it solely in terms of winning or losing lawsuits—clearly an approach that no longer meets the demands of today’s competitive business environment. Enterprises must update their mindset, regard patent litigation from a competitive perspective, learn and master various litigation strategies, and apply these strategies flexibly in practice. By doing so, patent litigation can better support companies in engaging in commercial competition, help them secure market share, safeguard their business outcomes, and ultimately enhance their economic performance.

Latest News

Post a comment