The second working meeting of the Intellectual Property and Data Compliance Professional Committee for 2023 was successfully held.


The “Second Working Meeting of the 2023 Intellectual Property and Data Compliance Professional Committee,” hosted by the Competition Task Force of the All China Lawyers Association, organized by the Intellectual Property and Data Compliance Committee of the Shinan District Lawyers Association and Shandong Chenggong Law Firm, and co-organized by Beijing Zhongyong (Qingdao) Law Firm, was held as scheduled on July 29, 2023, in the conference room of Chenggong (Laoshan) Law Firm. Huang Yongchao, Vice President of the Shinan District Lawyers Association of Qingdao, attended the meeting and delivered a speech. The session was chaired by Zhang Wang, Director of the Intellectual Property and Data Compliance Committee of the Shinan District Lawyers Association, Senior Partner at Chenggong Law Firm, and Head of the IP Specialized Committee. Also in attendance were Zhao Qingli, former Chief Judge of the Intellectual Property Division of the Xicheng District People’s Court in Beijing; Professor Qin Yong, Chair of the Faculty Committee of the School of Humanities and Law at China University of Petroleum (East China); Cao Gaoming, Partner at Chenggong (Qingdao Free Trade Zone) Law Firm; and Niu Yali, Partner at Chenggong (Laoshan) Law Firm, among other lawyers.

During the event, Vice President Huang Yongchao welcomed the guest speakers and all attendees, and introduced the Qingdao Shinan District Lawyers Association to the guests.

Presiding Judge Zhao Qingli shared her insights from the following five perspectives:
I. A Brief Discussion on the Criteria for Evaluating a “Good Lawyer”: A lawyer who effectively safeguards the legitimate rights and interests of their clients is, by definition, a good lawyer. At the same time, Chief Justice Zhao maintains that a good lawyer is also an accomplished legal scholar, dedicated to researching pressing issues and producing a substantial body of scholarly works.
II. Chief Judge Zhao, by analyzing real‑world cases, has distilled practical experience and lessons learned in intellectual property litigation for attorneys. (1) The plaintiff’s counsel lacked sufficient evidence‑gathering capabilities, resulting in an unfavorable outcome. (2) By identifying the key points of defense and presenting adequate evidence, the attorney successfully achieved the litigation objectives. (3) A weak awareness of civil procedural rules led to the plaintiff’s exercise of rights being inconsistent with the provisions of the Civil Procedure Law. (4) The plaintiff was improperly designated as a party; despite clarification, the plaintiff persisted in pursuing the action. (5) The plaintiff waived certain procedural rights, such as requesting an expert appraisal, and consequently bore the corresponding consequences. (6) The representing attorney demonstrated a lack of responsibility, allowing elementary errors in the plaintiff’s identity documents and authorization procedures to go uncorrected in a timely manner. (7) Due to the attorney’s negligence, the case was not thoroughly understood throughout the proceedings. (8) Opportunities for mediation were missed, preventing the attainment of the most favorable litigation outcomes for the client.
III. Intellectual property litigation attorneys must maintain open communication with their clients, enhance their abilities in evidence gathering and utilization, and improve their case‑searching skills, while also strengthening their courtroom advocacy, as well as their capacities for predictive analysis and decisive judgment.
IV. Several Procedural Points Requiring Attention in Intellectual Property Litigation: (1) Matters to Consider in the Preparation of Litigation Documents; (2) Matters to Consider in the Review of Jurisdictional Objections; (3) Matters to Consider When Applying for Property Preservation; (4) Matters to Consider When Applying for a Pre‑litigation Temporary Injunction in Intellectual Property Cases; (5) Matters to Consider Regarding Attorney Representation in Enforcement Proceedings.

V. Several Recommendations for Litigation Lawyers Attending Court Hearings: (1) Thoroughly prepare before the hearing and maintain a professional courtroom demeanor. (2) Manage speaking time carefully to avoid digressions or off‑topic remarks. (3) Stay well‑rested and attentive, paying close attention to the judge’s questions. (4) Make effective use of the courtroom argument stage; refrain from merely reading from your prepared script. (5) Remain firm on matters of principle and uphold the proper stance expected in litigation.

Finally, Professor Qin Yong highly commended the conference for its forward-looking vision, professional rigor, and distinctive perspective, summarizing its key takeaways and praising its breadth as well as its depth. He concluded by expressing his gratitude to Chief Justice Zhao for his insightful presentation, which provided us with a truly enriching auditory experience. He also expressed his anticipation that future events in the field of intellectual property will be both sustained and demonstrative of tangible IP‑related achievements.

 

 

Latest News

Post a comment