Turn the tide and uphold justice! Li Peng of Chenggong Law Firm was presented with a letter of gratitude from his client.


On November 22, 2022, Ms. Li, the client, made a special trip to the headquarters of Shandong Chenggong Law Firm to present Attorney Li Peng, who had represented her in her labor dispute case, with a banner inscribed with the words “Upholding the Ethical Standards of the Legal Profession and Safeguarding Judicial Justice.” The golden characters gleam with the radiance of fairness and justice, serving as both recognition and encouragement of Chenggong lawyers’ professional competence and ethical conduct, and as the highest praise for their dedicated representation. This gesture will inspire Chenggong attorneys to remain committed to the principle of “serving the people,” guided by the Party’s leadership and the spirit and culture of the Chenggong Way, to forge ahead with determination and courage on the path of upholding social fairness and justice.
 
 
Case Summary:
  
Ms. Li, who has worked at her employer for 11 years, was placed on maternity leave. During this period, without prior consultation or notice, her employer demoted her from her position as a senior counter manager overseeing four stores in Tianjin and Qingdao—down two grades—to an entry-level sales role, thereby forcing her to terminate her labor contract. To safeguard her lawful rights and interests, Ms. Li retained our firm’s attorneys to file for labor arbitration. However, since she had submitted a “Notice of Forced Termination of Labor Contract” to her employer before the end of her maternity leave, the arbitration commission dismissed her claim for economic compensation, reasoning that “the applicant failed to provide evidence demonstrating that her salary and benefits would be reduced following the job reassignment.” Left with no other option, Ms. Li sought out Chenggong Law Firm and entrusted Attorney Li Peng of our firm to file a lawsuit with the People’s Court on her behalf.
 
Following a thorough and meticulous analysis by Attorney Li Peng, the focus of this case was swiftly narrowed to “how to demonstrate that, while Ms. Li’s maternity leave had not yet concluded, the employer’s reassignment effectively resulted in a reduction in her wages and benefits.” To this end, the counsel compiled, consolidated, and scrutinized a wide array of evidence—among which the bank‑statement records detailing Ms. Li’s past salary income alone spanned 58 pages, containing nearly 4,000 entries. Additionally, more than 70 pages of tables were prepared to elucidate the employer’s compensation‑management system and the changes in Ms. Li’s salary components before and after her reassignment, with each page listing 66 distinct items. Such voluminous and complex evidentiary materials demanded painstaking, item‑by‑item verification, selection, and analysis by the attorney, enabling a step‑by‑step unraveling of the case and ultimately the formulation of a legally sound service plan that clearly delineates the case’s key issues and trajectory.
 
In addition to meticulously reviewing and analyzing a substantial body of evidence, the counsel worked around the clock to examine and compile case law, organize statutory provisions, and draft a structured framework for cross-examination, oral arguments, and the closing brief. By the time of the trial, they had assembled over ten thousand words of written submissions. Thanks to such thorough preparation, during the more than three-hour hearing, the counsel remained fully confident, conducting the proceedings with well-reasoned, evidence-based arguments and handling each point with ease.
 
Ultimately, the first-instance judgment cleared up the confusion and turned the tide! The court of first instance held that the employer’s reassignment effectively amounted to a pay cut, rendering the reassignment neither reasonable nor lawful, and ordered the employer to pay Ms. Li economic compensation in the amount of RMB 224,595.36.
 
Following the first-instance judgment, the employer appealed to the Qingdao Intermediate People’s Court. Through the diligent communication, mediation, and conciliation efforts of the representing counsel, the parties ultimately reached a settlement with a cap of RMB 160,000. The employer has now promptly and fully fulfilled its payment obligations as stipulated in the mediated agreement. As a result, the client, Ms. Li, not only achieved a satisfactory outcome but has also been able to put the litigation behind her and move forward into a new chapter.
 

Latest News

Post a comment