Li Yunfeng and Cao Gaoming received a banner of gratitude from the client in the franchise case.
Release date:
2022-10-20 09:47
Source:
On October 14, 2022, Client Mr. Li visited Shandong Chenggong (Huangdao) Law Firm to present a banner inscribed with the words “Exemplary Lawyers Who Dedicate Themselves with Utmost Care; Passionate and Professional Advocates Upholding Justice” to the two attorneys handling his case: Li Yunfeng, Managing Partner, Executive Director, and Director of Chenggong (Huangdao) Law Firm; and Cao Gaoming, Partner at Chenggong (Qingdao Free Trade Zone) Law Firm. Mr. Li expressed high praise and full recognition for the professional competence and dedicated spirit demonstrated by the two lawyers throughout the course of the case, and extended his gratitude for the tailored, specialized legal services provided by Chenggong’s attorneys.

01 Case Summary
The case concerns a dispute arising from a franchise agreement. On January 13, 2022, the plaintiff, Yang (hereinafter referred to as the “Franchisee”), filed suit in the Huangdao District People’s Court against the defendant, Qingdao Mou Catering Culture Communication Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the “Franchisor”), seeking termination of the cooperation agreement, a refund of fees, and compensation for losses. The plaintiff alleged that the Franchisor had failed to file for commercial franchise registration with the competent authority under the Ministry of Commerce, had not applied for trademark registration for the project at issue, had not met the basic “two stores within one year” requirement, and had not lawfully disclosed to the plaintiff, as required by the Regulations on the Administration of Commercial Franchising, the prices and terms relating to products, services, and equipment.
02 The Attorney’s Representation Process
The court of first instance held that, because the franchisee lacked the requisite franchise‑operating qualifications and failed to provide a registered or pending‑registration trademark as agreed, and also neglected to fulfill its statutory disclosure obligations prior to entering into the franchise agreement, such conduct constituted a fundamental breach of contract. Accordingly, the court granted all of the franchisor’s claims, ordering the termination of the franchise agreement between the franchisor and the franchisee, the refund of fees, and compensation for losses.
During the second-instance proceedings, the counsel reorganized the evidence to establish the following: 1) The franchisor’s legal representative holds the lawful exclusive right to the trademark at issue in the case and is therefore entitled to license it to the franchisee; 2) Although the franchisor lacks the requisite franchise‑operation qualifications and does not meet the “two stores for one year” criterion, this requirement is a regulatory provision rather than a substantive invalidity ground, and thus does not render the contract void or terminate it; 3) The franchisor has fulfilled its obligation to disclose material information, and any information that was not disclosed would not have a substantial impact on the formation or performance of the contract, nor would it prevent the achievement of the contract’s purpose; 4) The franchisor has, in fact, performed its principal contractual obligations, and the franchisee has already commenced operations under the agreement and generated actual profits.
Following the presentation and cross-examination of evidence during the trial, the franchisee’s stance—demanding that the franchisor refund all fees and compensate for losses—underwent a shift. Under the court’s mediation, the parties reached a settlement agreement, ultimately each conceding on their respective positions and resolving the dispute amicably. In the end, thanks to the agent’s efforts, the case successfully safeguarded the franchisor’s legitimate rights and interests and minimized its financial losses.
Latest News
Post a comment