Lost at first instance but won on appeal! See how attorneys Wang Bin and Deng Guihua turned the tide.


Recently, the client, Ms. Zhai, made a special trip to Chenggong (Huangdao) Law Firm to present two thank-you banners—each inscribed with “Promoting good and deterring evil, speaking out with righteousness, upholding integrity and justice” and “Wielding the sword of law, warming the hearts of the vulnerable”—to her attorneys, Wang Bin and Deng Guihua, thereby expressing her gratitude and recognition for their dedicated service.
 
 
Case Summary: In 2021, Ms. Zhai and Mr. Qu jointly operated a stone‑paving business. In 2013, the two parties settled their partnership interests, with Ms. Zhai receiving one property as partial payment. In 2021, Ms. Wang, Mr. Qu’s wife, contended that her husband had breached his marital duty of fidelity and thus lacked the authority to gift the property to Ms. Zhai, filing a lawsuit with the court to rescind the gift. Ms. Zhai retained Attorney Deng Guihua of Chenggong Law Firm (Huangdao) as her legal representative. Following investigation, the court of first instance ruled against Ms. Zhai. Dissatisfied with this decision, she retained Chenggong attorneys once again and filed an appeal. As is well known, prevailing on appeal after losing at first instance is extremely challenging. Nevertheless, Attorneys Deng Guihua and Wang Bin meticulously re-examined the facts, thoroughly reorganized and analyzed the case, and submitted new evidence demonstrating that Ms. Wang sought to deprive Ms. Zhai of her lawful property by occupying the “moral high ground.” They also skillfully employed a litigation strategy centered on the allocation of the burden of proof, arguing that Ms. Wang bore a heightened standard of proof—beyond mere “high probability”—to establish the gift. Through active communication with the judge and the submission of detailed legal briefs, they ensured that the entire appellate proceedings were conducted in a manner that was both reasoned, forceful, and advantageous. Ultimately, the Qingdao Intermediate People’s Court overturned the first‑instance judgment, finding that neither Ms. Wang nor Mr. Qu had sufficiently proven the existence of the gift. The court upheld our client’s position, confirming that the property in question is Ms. Zhai’s personal property and thereby fully safeguarding her legitimate rights and interests.

Latest News

Post a comment