Reversed judgment and victory! Lin Honggang and Bian Xiaohan received a banner of gratitude from their client.
Release date:
2022-08-29 09:07
Source:
Autumn is the season of harvest. On August 25, 2022, the clients—Mr. Song, Mr. Zhang, and Ms. Zhuang—made a special trip to Chenggong (Laoshan) Law Firm to present two banners of gratitude to their attorneys, Partners Lin Honggang and Bian Xiaohan, bearing the inscriptions “Guardians of Justice, Good Lawyers for the People” and “Diligent and Responsible in Protecting Rights, Legal Aid Demonstrating Justice,” thereby expressing their full appreciation and high praise for the firm’s professional expertise and efficient legal services.


This was, at first glance, a perfectly ordinary debt dispute. In 2018, the defendant in this case issued promissory notes to Mr. Song and Mr. Zhang, acknowledging an outstanding debt of over RMB 130,000 for transportation fees incurred in that year.
In 2019, the defendant in this case made additional payments to Mr. Song and Mr. Zhang for transportation expenses incurred in 2019; however, the amounts acknowledged in the 2018 promissory note remained unpaid, despite repeated requests by Mr. Zhang and Mr. Song.
In 2020, Mr. Zhang and Mr. Song filed a lawsuit with the court, seeking a judgment ordering the defendant to pay the outstanding debt specified in the promissory note. Citing insufficient evidence, the court of first instance dismissed their claim on the grounds that the defendant had already repaid the debt. Subsequently, Mr. Zhang and Mr. Song went to the appeal‑filing window of the Qingdao Intermediate People’s Court. At that time, Attorney Bian Xiaohan was on duty at the window. After reviewing the case, Attorney Bian conducted a thorough legal analysis and decided, together with Attorney Lin Honggang, to jointly represent the parties in the second‑instance proceedings.
The primary challenge in the second-instance proceedings lies in proving that the payments made by the defendant through a third-party payment platform in 2019 do not correspond to the amounts specified in the promissory note. To this end, Lin Honggang and Bian Xiaohan repeatedly contacted the third-party payer and the travel agency that provided the vehicle in 2019, and, by retrieving WeChat records and other means, ultimately secured crucial evidence for the case.
In August 2022, the Qingdao Intermediate People’s Court, in its second-instance ruling, reversed the lower court’s decisions in both cases and upheld the claims of Mr. Zhang and Mr. Song, achieving a result that satisfied the clients.
Latest News
Post a comment